2 Samuelchapter 17
29 verses · BSB2 Samuel book hub →
Key verse
Furthermore, Ahithophel said to Absalom, “Let me choose twelve thousand men and set out tonight in pursuit of David.
It stands in scene A of the chapter, verses 1 to 14.
The chapter
Chapter summary
Ahithophel's plan is militarily perfect: give me twelve thousand men, pursue tonight while he is weary and weak-handed, strike the king only, and bring all the people back. Hushai's counter-plan is theater and buys the night, thy father is a mighty man, and chafed in his mind as a bear robbed of her whelps; gather all Israel from Dan to Beersheba and go in person. Absalom prefers it, and the narrator says why: 'Jehovah had ordained to defeat the good counsel of Ahithophel, to the intent that Jehovah might bring evil upon Absalom.' The warning goes by Jonathan and Ahimaaz, hidden in a well at Bahurim. Ahithophel sets his house in order and hangs himself.
Context
History · Nathan, Gad · 2 Samuel overview
Where the chapter sits
2 Samuel 17 falls in Consequences: Amnon, Absalom, Sheba, the census (chapters 13–24). Tamar's violation; Amnon murdered; Absalom's rebellion; David's flight; Absalom's death; Sheba's revolt; the census and plague; the threshing floor of Araunah.
Before it: The Fall: Bathsheba and Uriah, chapters 11–12.
The whole shape of 2 Samuel→The world behind this chapter
2 Samuel 17The history
Two military plans are on the table, and both are competent. Ahithophel wants twelve thousand men moving tonight to catch a tired column and kill one man, which would end the war before it starts. Hushai argues for calling up the full national levy from Dan to Beersheba with Absalom at its head, flattering, slow, and fatal, because it gives David time to cross the river and organize.
The rest of the history, and what it meant to them
Hushai wins by using images a soldier feels. A bear robbed of her cubs, a veteran who will not sleep with the troops, and a whole nation so numerous it could drag a city's stones into a riverbed with ropes. Ropes on walls was a real siege technique, not a figure of speech.
The escape turns on a village courtyard. Houses had cisterns or wells in the yard, and a woman spreads a covering over the mouth and scatters crushed grain on it to dry, an ordinary domestic sight nobody would look twice at, with two royal messengers hidden underneath.
Ahithophel's end is told with legal precision: he saddles his donkey, goes home to his own town, sets his house in order, and hangs himself, and is buried in his father's tomb. Putting his affairs in order first was the act of a man who knew exactly what a failed conspiracy costs and chose the timing himself. Meanwhile the supplies that arrive at Mahanaim are listed like an inventory, beds, basins, pottery, wheat, barley, beans, honey, curds, and sheep, because men east of the Jordan were feeding an army in the field.
What it meant to them
The narrator gives away the point in one sentence: the LORD had ordained to defeat the good counsel of Ahithophel. The first hearers were watching a war decided in a council chamber, by an argument, before a sword was drawn.
For a people whose survival often hung on which adviser the king believed, that was the lesson, the best advice in Israel lost because God had already answered a prayer said on a hilltop two chapters earlier.
Sources cited
- John H. Walton, Victor H. Matthews & Mark W. Chavalas, The IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament
- Keil & Delitzsch, Biblical Commentary on the Books of Samuel
A. Jehovah defeats the good counsel of Ahithophel
1. (vv. 1-3)
a.Ahithophel proposes a narrow strike: twelve thousand men, one night, one target. His plan is surgical rather than a general war, smite the king only and bring all the people back in peace, and Matthew Henry hears the shape of Caiaphas at John 11:50 in it, one man dying so the nation need not perish. This is Ahithophel's second counsel in as many chapters; his first, the seizing of David's concubines at 16:21, had already been carried out exactly as he gave it.
2 Samuel 17:1, 3 voicesWhat preachers and commentators have said about these verses, in their own words.
2 Samuel 17:1
“This night - The night of the day on which David fled, and Absalom entered into Jerusalem. Ahithophel’s idea was to fall upon David by surprise, and in the first confusion of the surprised army to seize and kill David only.”
2 Samuel 17:1-11
“But his dexterity was chiefly displayed in that part of his counsel which recommended a general levy throughout the country; and that Absalom should take command of it in person--thereby flattering at once the pride and ambition of the usurper. The bait was caught by the vainglorious and wicked prince.”
Jamieson, Fausset & Brown· Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed
2 Samuel 17:1-3
“Let that one man die for the people, John xi. Kill the heir, and the inheritance shall be ours, Matt. xxi. But the counsel of them both was turned into foolishness.”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2 Samuel 17:3, 1 voice
2 Samuel 17:3
The man whom thou seekest - namely, David. Ahithophel means to say: “If I can only smite David, there will be no civil war, all the people will peaceably submit.”
2. (vv. 4-6)
a.The saying pleases Absalom, but he still calls for Hushai's word before acting on it, a fickleness Barnes reads as providence keeping the door open a second time. Hushai's presence in the council chamber is no accident: David had sent him back from the ascent of Olivet at 15:32-37 with one assignment, to defeat the counsel of Ahithophel, and this is the moment that assignment is tested. Absalom's own question, if not, speak thou, invites the very contradiction that will undo him.
3. (vv. 7-13)
a.Hushai concedes what everyone in the room already knows, that Ahithophel's counsel has generally been sound, and stakes his objection only on this time, which gives his dissent the appearance of fairness rather than rivalry. His argument is picture and flattery together: David and his mighty men are a bear robbed of her whelps, too dangerous to be caught by surprise, so let Absalom instead gather all Israel from Dan to Beersheba and lead the host himself, as the sand of the sea for multitude. Every word plays to the young man's vanity and buys David the one thing Ahithophel's plan would have denied him, time.
2 Samuel 17:7, 2 voices
2 Samuel 17:7
“And Hushai said to Absalom,.... Having leave to give his opinion freely: the counsel that Ahithophel hath given is not good at this time; he owns that Ahithophel was a good counsellor, and that the counsel he gave was for the most part, if not always, good, but what he gave at this time was not so; the wisest of men may sometimes be mistaken. Abarbinel thinks he respects his former counsel, particularly that that was good, advising him to defile his father's bed, 2Sa 16:21; but this was not, for which he gives the following reasons.”
2 Samuel 17:7
“At this time - Rather, “The counsel which Ahithophel has given this time is not good.” He contrasts it with that given before 2Sa 16:21, which was good. This gave an appearance of candour to his conduct, and so gave weight to his dissent. Observe the working of David’s prayer 2Sa 15:31.”
2 Samuel 17:9, 1 voice
2 Samuel 17:9
“Some pit, or in some other place - The Hebrew has “in one of the pits,” or “in one of the places.” Hence, “place” must have some defined meaning. It probably is used here, as elsewhere, for a “dwelling-house” or “village,” which might in that district be fortified houses 2Sa 17:12; 1Sa 26:25. Hushai’s argument is that there was no chance of seizing David by surprise as Ahithophel suggested.”
2 Samuel 17:10, 2 voices
2 Samuel 17:10
“And he also that is valiant, whose heart is as the heart of a lion, shall utterly melt,.... That is, whoever should hear of Absalom's forces, or a part of them, being routed, would be intimidated, though ever so courageous, or of such a lion-like temper and disposition; and even Ahithophel himself, notwithstanding all his boasted courage, his heart would fail, he would melt like water (h), Jos 7:5; should he meet with such a rebuff at first setting out.”
2 Samuel 17:10
“One of them would chase a thousand. [3.] They were all exasperated against Absalom, who was the author of all this mischief, were chafed in their minds, and would fight with the utmost fury; so that, what with their courage, and what with their rage, there would be no standing before them, especially for such raw soldiers as Absalom's generally were.”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2 Samuel 17:11, 1 voice
2 Samuel 17:11
“Therefore I counsel,.... My advice is as follows: that all Israel be generally gathered unto thee, from Dan even to Beersheba, as the sand that is by the sea for multitude: not all the inhabitants of the land, but such as are fit to bear arms, or that were soldiers, employed in military affairs, in keeping garrisons, guarding the coasts, &c. even the militia of the nation, from the extreme boundary of it on the north to the extreme boundary of it on the south; in such a direction lay Dan and Beersheba.”
2 Samuel 17:12, 1 voice
2 Samuel 17:12
“Perhaps Absalom was better pleased with the design of cutting off all the men that were with him, having a particular antipathy to some of David's friends, than with Ahithophel's project of smiting the king only.”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2 Samuel 17:13, 2 voices
2 Samuel 17:13
“Shall all Israel bring ropes to that city - The original word חבלים chabalim, which signifies ropes, and from which we have our word cable, may have some peculiarity of meaning here; for it is not likely that any city could be pulled down with ropes. The Chaldee, which should be best judge in this case, translates the original word by משרין mashreyan, towers: this gives an easy sense.”
Adam Clarke· Commentary on the Bible (1810-1826)evangelical
2 Samuel 17:13
“As dew - That is, plenteously, suddenly, irresistibly, and on all sides; for so the dew falls. Bring ropes - It is an hyperbolical expression, suited to the vain-glorious temper of this insolent young man: implying, that they would do so if they could not destroy him another way: or, that they should be enough to do so, if there were occasion.”
John Wesley· Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical
4. (v. 14)
a.The narrator states the theology of the whole rebellion in one clause: the Lord had appointed to defeat the good counsel of Ahithophel, to the intent that the Lord might bring evil upon Absalom. Hushai's flattering speech works because Absalom wants it to work, and the text credits the outcome to God rather than to Hushai's rhetoric. It is the answer to David's prayer at 15:31, O Lord, I pray thee, turn the counsel of Ahithophel into foolishness, given almost word for word.
2 Samuel 17:14, 1 voice
2 Samuel 17:14
“For what shall we say about Hushai's pious deception of Absalom for the sake of King David's safety which, although formulated with good will by the deceiver and cheater and opposed to the well-being of the questioner, is approved by the text of divine Scripture that says, "By the will of the Lord the useful advice of Ahithophel was undone, so that the Lord might bring evil upon Absalom"?”
John Cassian· written before 435· CONFERENCE 17.19.5patristic
B. A cloth spread over a well at Bahurim
1. (vv. 15-16)
a.Hushai reports both counsels to Zadok and Abiathar the priests, still stationed in Jerusalem watching the city for David, and sends them running with the one order that matters, do not lodge in the plains of the wilderness tonight. The urgency is deliberate: Hushai has bought time with his speech, but he does not trust Absalom to stay talked out of Ahithophel's plan for long. The priests become the relay in a chain that already includes their own sons waiting outside the city walls.
2 Samuel 17:15, 2 voices
2 Samuel 17:15-16
“For in the history, Hushai is mentioned as the chief companion of David and the son of Arachi, but in the psalm, Hushai is the son of Jemini. Neither he nor any other of those appearing in the history was the son of Jemini. Perhaps he was called the son of Jemini for this reason, because he displayed great valor and strength through a mere pretense of friendship, going over, as he pretended, to Absalom, but in reality thwarting the plans of Ahithophel, a very skilled man, well trained in military affairs, who was giving his counsel.”
Basil of Caesarea· written before 379· HOMILIES ON THE PSALMS 7.1patristic
2 Samuel 17:15
“But, it should seem, he was not sure but that yet Ahithophel's counsel might be followed, and was therefore jealous lest, if he made not the best of his way, the king would be swallowed up, and all the people that were with him,”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2 Samuel 17:16, 1 voice
2 Samuel 17:16
“Hushai, like a wise and prudent man, knowing, too, Absalom’s weak and fickle character, would not depend upon the resolution, taken at his instigation, not to pursue the king, but took instant measures to advertise David of his danger.”
2. (vv. 17-21)
a.Jonathan and Ahimaaz, the priests' sons, wait outside the city at En-rogel because they cannot risk being seen going in, and a servant girl carries the message to them, an ordinary courier for word that will decide whether David lives. Discovered by a boy and pursued to Bahurim, they go down into a well in a man's courtyard, and the woman of the house spreads a covering and ground corn over the mouth of it, hiding two fugitives under a household chore. Barnes notes that had Absalom's servants found her still in the courtyard the spread grain might have given her away; instead they search, find nothing, and go home.
2 Samuel 17:17, 3 voices
2 Samuel 17:17
“En-rogel - See the marginal reference. A wench - Hebrew “the maid servant,” namely, of the high priest, either Zadok or Abiathar, or possibly one employed in some service in the temple courts. (1Sa 2:22 note.) And they went and told king David - As related afterward 2Sa 17:21. Here mentioned by anticipation.”
2 Samuel 17:17
“If she carried the message by word of mouth, there was danger of her making some mistake or blunder in it; but Providence can make an ignorant girl a trusty messenger, and serve its wise counsels by the foolish things of the world.”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2 Samuel 17:17
“The young priests that were to be the messengers were forced to retire secretly out of the city, by En-rogel, which signifies, as some say, the fountain of a spy. Surely it went ill with Jerusalem when two such faithful priests as they were might not be seen to come into the city.”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2 Samuel 17:18, 2 voices
2 Samuel 17:18
“The woman of the house very ingeniously covered the mouth of the well with a cloth, on which she spread corn to dry, so that the pursuers were not aware that there was a well; else they would have searched it,”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2 Samuel 17:18
“They, being aware that they were discovered, sheltered themselves in a friend's house in Bahurim, where David had refreshed himself but just before, ch. xvi. There they were happily hidden in a well, which now, in summer time, perhaps was dry,”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2 Samuel 17:19, 2 voices
2 Samuel 17:19-20
“And what shall we say about the deed of the woman who received those who had been sent to King David by the aforementioned Hushai and who hid them in a well, spreading a cover over the mouth of it and making believe that she was drying barley? "They went on," she said, "after having drunk a little water," and by this trick she saved them from the hands of their pursuers. Tell me, then, I ask you, what you would have done if a similar situation had arisen for you who now live under the gospel.”
John Cassian· written before 435· CONFERENCE 17.19.6-7patristic
2 Samuel 17:19
“A covering - Hebrew “the covering,” perhaps “the hanging” or “awning” at the door of the house, as the word seems to mean when spoken of the tabernacle. Ground corn - Or “peeled barley,” which she spread out as if for the purpose of drying it in the sun.”
2 Samuel 17:20, 1 voice
2 Samuel 17:20
“As soon as ever she had hid the men she went into the house, as if busy about her usual occupations. Had Absalom’s servants, who had had information from some of the people of Bahurim that the men had come to this house, found her in the court it might have directed their attention to the peeled barley. Over the brook of water - Compare 2Sa 16:9 note. The word for “brook” (“Michal”) occurs only here. One has been found in this very district, still so called.”
3. (v. 22)
a.All of David's company crosses the Jordan by morning light, and the narrator adds a detail he did not owe the reader, there lacked not one of them. Henry reads the completeness of the crossing as a figure of the greater Son of David, who said of those the Father gave him, of all that thou hast given me have I lost none, a likeness he draws rather than a citation the text itself makes. The flight becomes an orderly deliverance rather than a rout, every person accounted for on the far bank.
2 Samuel 17:22, 2 voices
2 Samuel 17:22
“Then David arose, and all the people that were with him, and passed over Jordan,.... Taking the advice of Hushai: by the morning light there lacked not one of them that was not gone over Jordan; they travelled all night, and before it was morning they had all passed the river in boats, or through the fords, and not one was lost in the passage, nor any deserted, see Joh 17:12; and now perhaps David penned the forty second and forty third psalms, Psa 42:1.”
2 Samuel 17:22
“But special notice is taken of this, that there lacked not one of them: none deserted him, though his distress was great, none staid behind sick or weary, nor were any lost or cast away in passing the river. Herein some make him a type of the Messiah, who said, in a difficult day, Of all that thou hast given me have I lost none.”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
C. Ahithophel sets his house in order and hangs himself
1. (v. 23)
a.Ahithophel sets his affairs in order and hangs himself, the only such death recorded in the Old Testament. The only other self-hanging in Scripture is Judas at Matthew 27:5, and the two men share more than a method. Psalm 41:9, mine own familiar friend which did eat of my bread hath lifted up his heel against me, is read by the church as David's word for Ahithophel, and John 13:18 has Jesus quote the same verse of Judas. Henry notes that Ahithophel was still buried in his father's tomb, an honor his own end did not forfeit.
2 Samuel 17:23, 2 voices
2 Samuel 17:23
“To his city - To Giloh (marginal reference). Ahithophel was probably influenced by deep mortification at the slight put upon him by rejecting his counsel. He is a memorable example of the impotence of worldly wisdom. Compare the marginal reference.”
2 Samuel 17:23
“It is well that that breath is stopped and that head laid from which nothing could be expected but mischief. It seems, it was not then usual to disgrace the dead bodies of self-murderers, for Ahithophel was buried, we may suppose honourably buried, in the sepulchre of his father, though he deserved no better than the burial of an ass.”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2. (vv. 24-26)
a.David reaches Mahanaim, the strong city across Jordan that had already sheltered Ish-bosheth in the civil war after Saul's death, while Absalom crosses behind him with the levy Hushai's counsel raised. Absalom replaces Joab with Amasa as captain of the host; the two commanders are cousins, Amasa's mother Abigail and Joab's mother Zeruiah both counted among Jesse's household, so the rebellion is a family quarrel fought with family generals on both sides. The appointment does not survive the war: Joab kills Amasa at Gibeon in chapter 20.
2 Samuel 17:24, 3 voices
2 Samuel 17:24
“Mahanaim - See 2Sa 2:8. The same reasons which induced Abner to choose it for Ishbosheth probablv made it a good rallying point for David. It was a strong city, in a well-provisioned country, with a mountainous district for retreat in case of need, and with a warlike and friendly population.”
2 Samuel 17:24
“Then David came to Mahanaim--in the high eastern country of Gilead, the seat of Ish-bosheth's government. Absalom passed over Jordan--It is not said how long an interval elapsed, but there must have been sufficient time to make the intended levy throughout the kingdom.”
Jamieson, Fausset & Brown· Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed
2 Samuel 17:24
“Not content that he had driven his good father to the utmost corner of his kingdom, he resolved to chase him out of the world. He pitched in the land of Gilead with all his forces, ready to give David battle,”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2 Samuel 17:25, 3 voices
2 Samuel 17:25
“Ithra an Israelite - Or “Jether the Ishmeelite” 1Ch 2:17. “Ithra” and “Jether” are practically the same names. “Israelite” in the text is wrong. It should be either “Ishmaelite” or “Jezreelite” 2Sa 3:2. Abigail the daughter of Nahash - If Zeruiah and Abigail were Jesse’s daughters, the only probable way of reconciling our text with 1Ch 2:16-17, is to suppose that Nahash was Jesse’s wife. If Zeruiah and Abigail were only sisters of David by the mother, then Nahash might be the name of her first husband.”
2 Samuel 17:25
“Amasa--By the genealogy it appears that this captain stood in the same relation to David as Joab, both being his nephews. Of course, Amasa was Absalom's cousin, and though himself an Israelite, his father was an Ishmaelite (1Ch 2:17). Nahash--is thought by some to be another name of Jesse, or according to others, the name of Jesse's wife.”
Jamieson, Fausset & Brown· Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed
2 Samuel 17:25-26
“It was not long since that Absalom himself fled for a crime, and David contented himself with his being an exile, though he deserved death, nay, he mourned and longed for him; but so perfectly void of all natural affection is this ungrateful Absalom that he eagerly thirsts after his own father's blood.”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2 Samuel 17:26, 1 voice
2 Samuel 17:26
“So Israel and Absalom pitched in the land of Gilead. Which belonged to the tribes of Reuben and Gad, and the half tribe of Manasseh; here the Israelites that were with Absalom encamped, in order to give battle to David and his men.”
D. Barzillai brings beds, wheat, and honey to Mahanaim
1. (vv. 27-29)
a.Shobi son of the Ammonite king, Machir who had sheltered Mephibosheth at Lo-debar, and Barzillai the Gileadite meet the fleeing king with beds, basins, grain, honey, cheese and flocks, for they said the people is hungry, and weary, and thirsty, in the wilderness. None of the three owes David an oath the way Jonathan's household does; their kindness comes from outside Israel's own rebellion, an Ammonite, a man from the town that once hid Saul's grandson, and an old Gileadite of great wealth. Barzillai's welcome here is repaid at 19:31-39, when David offers to carry him to Jerusalem and Barzillai sends his son Chimham in his place.
2 Samuel 17:27, 3 voices
2 Samuel 17:27
“Shobi’s father may have been the king of the Ammonites, and Shobi appointed by David as tributary king or governor of Ammon after he took Rabbah 2Sa 12:29. On the other hand, Nahash may have been a common name among the Ammonites, and the Nahash of 2Sa 17:25 may have been of that nation. On Machir, see the marginal reference.”
2 Samuel 17:27
“Shobi - Who, as it may seem, disliked and disowned that barbarous action to the ambassadors; and therefore, when the rest were destroyed, was left king or governor of the residue of the Ammonites.”
John Wesley· Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical
2 Samuel 17:27
“Those that think their prosperity most confirmed know not but, some time or other, they may stand in need of the kindness of those that now lie at their mercy, and may be glad to be beholden to them, which is a reason why we should, as we have opportunity, do good to all men, for he that watereth shall be watered also himself, when there is occasion.”
Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan
2 Samuel 17:28, 1 voice
2 Samuel 17:28
“Brought beds - These no doubt consisted in skins of beasts, mats, carpets, and such like things. Basons - ספות sappoth. Probably wooden bowls, such as the Arabs still use to eat out of, and to knead their bread in. Earthen vessels - כלי יוצר keley yotser. Probably clay vessels, baked in the sun. These were perhaps used for lifting water, and boiling those articles which required to be cooked.”
Adam Clarke· Commentary on the Bible (1810-1826)evangelical
2 Samuel 17:29, 2 voices
2 Samuel 17:29
“Cheese of kine - Or, as others, “milch cows,” which is more in accordance with the context, being coupled with “sheep,” and is more or less borne out etymologically by the Arabic. God’s care for David was evident in the kindness of these people.”
2 Samuel 17:29
“Being considered a luxurious refreshment (So 4:11), the supply of it shows the high respect that was paid to David by his loyal and faithful subjects at Mahanaim.”
Jamieson, Fausset & Brown· Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed
The text of this chapter
This page carries no textual note on 2 Samuel 17. Where this site has examined a place the manuscripts differ, the examination is in the manuscripts room. Every place this site examines →
This page draws on 10 works. Open for the list.
This page draws on Adam Clarke; Albert Barnes; Basil of Caesarea, HOMILIES ON THE PSALMS 7.1; Jamieson Fausset and Brown, Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible; Jamieson, Fausset & Brown, Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871); John Cassian; John Gill; John Wesley, Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765); Keil and Delitzsch, Biblical Commentary on the Books of Samuel and Matthew Henry.
Keep studying
On this page
Studies1
