Murmuring, from provision to judgment
Pattern
In Exodus every complaint in the wilderness is answered with bread, water or meat. In Numbers the same complaints bring fire, plague and forty years. Psalm 95 reads the whole story as a warning, and Hebrews quotes that psalm and applies it to its own readers.
The change between the two books is one of the most important things in the Torah, and neither book states it alone. The generation that was fed at Massah dies at Kadesh for the same voice raised again, and the New Testament says these things happened as examples. Harden not your hearts is Scripture's own sermon on this thread.
Bread answers the murmuring
The whole congregation murmurs for food, and God rains bread from heaven.
Water at Massah and Meribah
The people chide Moses for water and are given it; the place is named for the striving.
The fire of the Lord
In Numbers the same complaining is answered with burning, not bread.
These ten times
The sentence at Kadesh keeps its own count of the provocations.
Harden not your hearts
Psalm 95 reads Massah and Meribah as the standing warning.
Hebrews 3:7-11 you are here
Hebrews applies the psalm
The New Testament quotes Psalm 95 and turns the wilderness story on its own readers.
