Skip to content
mannafest.faith
Scripture: The text alone. Study: The verses explained. Original: The Hebrew and Greek, and the tradition.

Joshuachapter 19

51 verses · Joshua, by tradition · 15th or 13th century BC · History

According to the word of the Lord they gave him the city which he asked, even Timnath–serah in mount Ephraim: and he built the city, and dwelt therein.

Introduction

Joshua, by tradition, History, Joshua Overview.

This chapter finishes the division of the land with six lots, one after another. It stands in the book that tradition credits to Joshua. Its first hearers were the northern tribes and the small tribe of Simeon, and these names, towns and borders were their title to the ground they worked. The records vary in length, some giving borders and some only towns. The chapter ends with the leader who divided the land receiving his own share last. Listen for the tribe whose portion lies inside another's. Listen also for the tribe that had to go and find its ground elsewhere.

Context

Who
Simeon, Zebulun, Issachar, Asher, Naphtali and Dan, and a commander taking his portion last
What
The lots for Simeon, Zebulun, Issachar, Asher, Naphtali and Dan, and the town given to Joshua.
Where
The Negev within Judah for Simeon, Galilee and the Valley of Jezreel for the northern tribes, the coast near Joppa for Dan, and Timnath-serah in Ephraim for Joshua.
When
About 1400 BC on the traditional dating, at Shiloh, with Dan's move north to Leshem told from a later time.
Why
To complete the division of the land among the tribes, and to show Joshua taking his portion only after every tribe had its own.

Historical context

The chapter belongs to six tribes and closes on one man. Simeon draws second and receives towns cut out of Judah, and Dan draws last and receives the smallest ground of the seven.

Show the rest of the historical context, 6 more paragraphs

It stands at the end of the division, immediately after Benjamin's lot in chapter 18, and it closes the allotment at Shiloh where chapter 18 opened it.

The ground runs from the Negev towns of the far south through the lower Galilee hills and the eastern end of the Jezreel valley. It then runs up the coastal hills toward Sidon and Tyre, and down to the Philistine edge west of Judah.

The occasion is the completion of the survey and the casting of the six remaining lots over it.

A first hearer knew that Simeon's position inside Judah was the sentence of Genesis 49:7 arriving. Jacob had said God would divide Simeon and Levi in Jacob and scatter them in Israel, and Moses names every tribe but Simeon in Deuteronomy 33.

Such a hearer also knew the ground each portion sat on. Zebulun and Issachar took farming country on the trade routes, Asher took olive country running north toward Sidon, and Naphtali took the eastern hills above the lake.

The last thing a first hearer understood was how unusual the closing scene was. In the ancient world a commander took first and took most, and Joshua takes one town in the hills after every one of his men has been served.

Significance

The closing formula mattered to the people who heard it. These are the inheritances distributed by lot at Shiloh before the LORD at the door of the tent of meeting, and so they finished dividing the land.

Show the rest of the significance, 2 more paragraphs

For first hearers, Joshua going last was the closing note of his career. The man who could have named any valley in the country asked for a hill town and rebuilt it himself.

Dan's two verses about Leshem told them that a portion could be granted and still be lost, which is the tension the whole book leaves standing.

This chapter in Jewish lifeWhat this chapter is in Jewish life and reading.

How it is read

The corpus carries five kept notes of Rashi for this chapter, and the first of them explains the counting. The second lot is second to Benjamin's, because Benjamin's was the first of the seven, Judah and Joseph having already received theirs, and from here the text goes on to list the seven lots in order (Rashi on Joshua 19:1:1, the Metsudah Publications translation of 1997, CC-BY).

The note on Simeon is where the chapter's reading is decided, and it is a note about a curse turning into a placement. Judah's portion was larger than its due, so Simeon received its inheritance inside Judah's territory. Rashi's note records two reasons the commentators give. On one, Simeon helped Judah conquer that land and so earned a share of it. On the other, the arrangement carries out Jacob's own word over Simeon and Levi, that they would be divided in Jacob and scattered in Israel, "Shimon was given a portion within Yehudah and Levi was scattered throughout many cities in the land" (Rashi on Joshua 19:9:1). Read that way the boundary list is the record of a patriarch's sentence being executed, which is a reading a Christian reader will want to weigh against the text's own stated reason, that Judah's share was simply too large.

Three shorter notes are geographical and lexical. At the twelfth verse Rashi takes Chisloth Tabor from a word for flanks and explains the position precisely, near the middle of the slope and closer to the rear than the front, as against Aznoth Tabor which names a place near the top where the ears would be (Rashi on Joshua 19:12:1). At the thirteenth he identifies Gath Hepher as the city of the prophet Jonah son of Amittai (Rashi on Joshua 19:13:1), which quietly ties this list to a later book. At the twenty-ninth he reads the fortified city of Tyre as cities of fortress and cities of might (Rashi on Joshua 19:29:1).

Radak, Malbim and Metzudat David carry most of the commentary on this chapter, and the corpus carries their refs with the reason that Sefaria holds no English version of them, so they stand here cited and unquoted. Metzudat David runs from Joshua 19:7:1 to 19:30:1 at twelve places, Malbim at 19:3:1, 19:4:1, 19:5:1, 19:6:1 and 19:17:1, and Radak at 19:2:1 and 19:15:1.

What the rabbis say

The corpus carries forty rabbinic locators for this chapter and the text of none, so each is cited and linked here rather than quoted. They are spread across the tribal lists rather than gathered on one verse, and a large share of them come from the Jerusalem Talmud, which is where the boundaries of the land are argued because the agricultural laws depend on them.

On Simeon's portion inside Judah at the ninth verse the corpus holds Midrash Tannaim on Deuteronomy 32:9:4, Midrash Tehillim 90:1, and Sifrei Devarim 312:2 and 348:6. On Zebulun at the tenth it holds Bereshit Rabbah 98:11 with Jerusalem Talmud Sukkah 5:1:3 and 5:1:4; on Bethlehem of Zebulun at the fifteenth, Jerusalem Talmud Megillah 1:1:7; and on Issachar at the nineteenth and twentieth, Jerusalem Talmud Shabbat 14:3:8 and Vayikra Rabbah 9:1. On the twenty-second it holds Tractate Soferim 7:4, and on Asher at the twenty-fourth, Midrash Lekach Tov on Deuteronomy 33:25:1 and on Genesis 49:20:2, Midrash Sekhel Tov, Bereshit 49:20:1, and Otzar Midrashim under Lekach Tov on the Blessings of Yaakov Our Father 22.

The Galilean towns draw the tithing tractates. On the twenty-eighth and twenty-ninth the corpus holds Jerusalem Talmud Demai 2:1:17 and 1:1:4, with Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 773:7; on the thirty-fifth, Jerusalem Talmud Demai 2:1:19, Jerusalem Talmud Megillah 1:1:4, Makkot 10a:6 and Megillah 5b:14; on the thirty-eighth, Jerusalem Talmud Orlah 3:7:9. Naphtali at the thirty-second and thirty-third carries Midrash Tehillim 92:1, and Dan at the forty-first and forty-fourth carries Bamidbar Rabbah 10:5 and Jerusalem Talmud Sanhedrin 1:2:16. The migration of Dan at the forty-seventh carries Bekhorot 55a:17, Ein Yaakov, Bekhorot 9:1, Megillah 6a:15 and Midrash Lekach Tov, Genesis 33:18:1. The chapter's close, where Joshua receives Timnath Serah last of all, carries Midrash Lekach Tov, Numbers 26:55:1 and Sifrei Bamidbar 132:3 on the forty-ninth and fiftieth, Bava Batra 122a:12 with Ein Yaakov (Glick Edition), Bava Batra 8:16 and Ein Yaakov, Bava Batra 8:18 on the fiftieth, and Bamidbar Rabbah 3:7 and 21:9 with Ein Yaakov (Glick Edition), Yevamot 10:1 on the last verse, where the lot is cast at Shiloh before the door of the tent of meeting. The first verse carries Bereshit Rabbati, Parashat Vayechi 15 and the second, Jerusalem Talmud Pesachim 4:1:10. What each of them teaches is a saying of the rabbis, and is reported as theirs wherever this site quotes one. The quotations wait on a fetch that carries the text.

Sources: Rashi, Rashi on Joshua 19:1:1 to 19:29:1, The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, CC-BY; Metzudat David, Metzudat David on Joshua 19:7:1 to 19:30:1, twelve refs cited because the corpus carries no English text; Malbim, Malbim on Joshua 19:3:1, 19:4:1, 19:5:1, 19:6:1 and 19:17:1, cited by ref because the corpus carries no English text; Radak, Radak on Joshua 19:2:1 and 19:15:1, cited by ref because the corpus carries no English text; The Sefaria corpus, scripts/data/sources/sefaria/joshua/19.json, the 40 Talmud and Midrash locators of this chapter.

The heads below are this chapter's scenes. The numbered points under each are its verses.

Simeon settled inside Judah's oversized portion

Joshua 19:1-9

Simeon draws second and receives only towns cut out of Judah, and verse 9 gives the reason, that Judah's share was too large for them. Genesis 49:7 said of Simeon and Levi, "I will disperse them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel". This book fulfils both, Levi in cities among all the tribes in chapter 21 and Simeon in towns inside Judah.

Joshua 19:1

“The inheritance of Simeon was taken out of the portion of Judah, which proved on experience to be larger than the numbers of that tribe required. The Simeonite territory is described by its towns, of which fourteen were in the Negeb, and four others Jos 19:7 partly in the Negeb and partly in “the valley.” On the narrow confines here assigned to Simeon, and its insignificant position altogether among the Twelve tribes, see Deu 33:6 note. Jos 19:6 Thirteen - Fourteen names have been given.”

Gill reads Beersheba and Sheba as one town under two names, which keeps the total at thirteen in verse 6. Beersheba marks the southern end of the land in the phrase from Dan to Beersheba at Judges 20:1. Clarke refers the name to the oath of Genesis 21:31.

Joshua 19:2

“And they had in their inheritance Beersheba and Sheba,.... Or, Beersheba, that is, Sheba; for so the particle "vau" is sometimes used (z), and must be so used here; or otherwise, instead of thirteen, it will appear that there are fourteen cities, contrary to the account of them, Jos 19:6; so Kimchi and Ben Melech make them one city.”

All three names stand in Judah's southern list at 15:28-29, which shows these towns carved from Judah's portion. Gill matches Balah with Baalah there and with Bilhah in the Simeonite list of 1 Chronicles 4:29. Hazar-shual was resettled after the exile at Nehemiah 11:27.

Joshua 19:3

“Hazar-shual - For this and several of the following places, see the notes on Jos 15:32.”

Hormah is named for a destruction. Numbers 21:3 tells it once, and Judges 1:17 tells it again with Judah and Simeon fighting side by side, which suits a tribe settled inside Judah. Gill matches Bethul with Chesil at 15:30 and with Bethuel at 1 Chronicles 4:30.

Joshua 19:4

“And Eltolad, and Bethul, and Hormah. These were all cities of Judah, Jos 15:30; Eltolad is the same with Tolad, and Bethul with Bethuel, 1Ch 4:29, and with Chesil, Jos 15:30, mentioned there along with Hormah; See Gill on Jos 15:30.”

Clarke renders Beth-marcaboth house of chariots and supposes war chariots were kept there. The Simeonite list at 1 Chronicles 4:31 repeats the name beside Hazar-susim. It adds that they were Simeon's cities until David reigned.

Joshua 19:5

“Beth-marcaboth - The house or city of chariots. Probably a place where their war-chariots and cavalry were laid up.”

Barnes counts fourteen names for the thirteen cities of this verse. Gill closes the gap by reading Beersheba and Sheba in verse 2 as one place, as the Berean also renders it. Clarke gives Beth-lebaoth as house of lionesses, and Judah's list at 15:32 has the shorter form Lebaoth.

Joshua 19:6

“And Bethlebaoth, and Sharuhen,.... Whether the first is the same with Lebaoth, a city of Judah, Jos 15:32; and with the Bethleptepha of Josephus (b), and the Betholene of Pliny (c), is not certain: in this place secret to have been an idol temple of the Canaanites, dedicated to lions, as in Egypt there was a city called Leontopolis, from whence was the Leontopolitan nome, the inhabitants of which worshipped lions (d); and the Egyptians had temples dedicated to them, as Aelianus (e) relates.”

Barnes places these four partly in the Negev and partly in the valley. Gill keeps Ain and Rimmon apart to make up four towns, while Nehemiah 11:29 later names a single En-rimmon. Ashan later went to the priests, according to 1 Chronicles 6:57-59.

Baalath-beer marks the farthest reach of Simeon's villages, and its second name places it in the south country. The name Ramoth Negev recurs at 1 Samuel 30:27 among the towns to which David sent gifts. Clarke links the name to older worship there.

Joshua 19:8

“Baalath-beer - The well of the mistresses. Probably so called from some superstitious or impure worship set up there.”

Matthew Henry supposes the first survey overrated the land, so Judah's share proved more than the tribe could fill. Calvin credits Judah with restraint in yielding towns already assigned to it, when it could have pleaded God's authority and kept them. Simeon's towns came from that surplus.

Joshua 19:9

“The abundance of some must supply the wants of others, that there may be somewhat of an equality, for which there may be equity where there is not law. That which was thus taken off from Judah to be put into a new lot Providence directed to the tribe of Simeon, that Jacob's prophecy concerning this tribe might be fulfilled, I will divide them in Jacob.”

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

Zebulun and Issachar in the northern valleys

Joshua 19:10-16

the third lot came up: Zebulun is drawn before its elder brother Issachar, the same order Jacob uses at Genesis 49:13-14. Gath-hepher at verse 13 is the home of Jonah son of Amittai, named as such at 2 Kings 14:25. The Bethlehem of verse 15 lies in Galilee, a different town from the Bethlehem of Judah at Micah 5:2, and Nahalal returns at Judges 1:30 as Nahalol, a town Zebulun never cleared.

Joshua 19:10

Sarid, not yet identified, was evidently a leading topographical point on the south frontier of Zebulun. The boundary passed westward until it touched the Kishon, near “Tell Kaimon” (Jos 12:22 note), and thence, turned northward, leaving Carmel, which belonged to Asher, on its west. The territory of Zebulun accordingly would not anywhere reach to the Mediterranean, though its eastern side abutted on the sea of Galilee, and gave the tribe those “outgoings” attributed to it in the Blessing of Moses (Deu 33:18). Daberath (Jos 19:12) is probably “Deburieh.”

This is Zebulun's southern line, running west from Sarid to the brook near Jokneam, which Barnes takes as the Kishon, and the king of Jokneam is listed at 12:22. Barnes keeps Zebulun back from the Mediterranean, since Carmel went to Asher. Wesley gives it both seas, after Genesis 49:13.

Joshua 19:11

“Toward the sea - The lot of this tribe was washed by the midland sea on the west, and by the sea of Tiberias on the east, answering Jacob's prophecy, Zebulun shall be an haven of ships; trading ships on the great sea, and fishing ships on the sea of Galilee.”

John Wesley · Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical

the border of Chisloth–tabor: From Sarid the line runs east to the foot of Mount Tabor, where Gill has Zebulun meeting Issachar. Daberath on this line is given to the Levites from Issachar at 21:28, so the town sat on the seam of the two tribes. Deborah sends Barak to Mount Tabor at Judges 4:6.

Gill takes this as the eastern side, ending at Neah. Barnes places Rimmon about six miles north of Nazareth and finds it among the Levite towns, where 1 Chronicles 6:77 spells it Rimmono. Both Rimmon and Gath-hepher lie a short way from Nazareth by his account.

Joshua 19:13

“And from thence passeth on along on the east to Gittahhepher,.... Which was the native place of Jonah the prophet, 2Ki 14:25; and where Jerom says (r) his grave was shown, and was a small village in his time two miles from Sippore, then called Diocaesarea: to Ittahkazin; of this place we have no account elsewhere, but it was not far from the former: and goeth out to Remmonmethoar to Neah; where the eastern border ended.”

1 more voice on this verse

Joshua 19:13

“Gittah (or Gath)- hepher, the birthplace of the prophet Jonah 2Ki 14:25, is probably the modern village of El-Meshhad, where the tomb of the prophet is still shown, a short way from Nazareth, on the road to Tiberias. Remmon-methoar to Neah - Read “and goeth out to Remmon, which reacheth to Neah.” (See the margin.) Rimmon, a Levitical city Jos 21:35; 1Ch 6:77 is probably the modern “Rummaneh,” in the plain of “El Buttauf,” about six miles north of Nazareth.”

The border now closes on the north side. Barnes records a view that Hannathon is Cana of Galilee, the town of the wedding at John 2:1. He identifies the Valley of Iphtah-el with the district of Jotapata, which Josephus held against the Roman legions of Vespasian.

Joshua 19:14

Hannathon, more properly Channathon, has been supposed by some to be the Cana of Galilee of the New Testament, and Jiphthah-el is probably the present “Jefat”; the “Jotapata” of Roman times, which was so long and valiantly defended by Josephus against the legions of Vespasian. The “Valley” is the “Wady Abilin”; and Bethlehem Jos 19:15 is the present miserable village of “Beit-Lahin.”

Five towns are named here against a total of twelve, and Barnes concludes that seven names have dropped out of the text. Wesley counts the boundary points too and treats the extra names as places on the border or in other tribes. The two readings leave the count open.

Joshua 19:15

“Beth-lehem - Not that where Christ was born, which was in Judah, but another. Twelve cities - There are more numbered here, but the rest either were not cities properly so called, or were not within this tribe, but only bordering upon it, and belonging to other tribes.”

John Wesley · Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical

1 more voice on this verse

Joshua 19:15

“Twelve cities - Only five have been mentioned, and the names in the verses preceding are apparently not names of Zebulonite cities, but merely of points in or near the boundary line. It would therefore appear that seven names have disappeared from the text, and perhaps also the definition of the western frontier.”

The whole record on this verse →

The summary closes Zebulun's portion. Gill notes that the tribe held towns beyond this list, and Kartah and Dimnah are given to the Levites from Zebulun at 21:35. Deuteronomy 33:18 blesses Zebulun in its travels, and Barnes ties that line to the tribe's shore on the Sea of Galilee.

Joshua 19:16

“This is the inheritance of the children of Zebulun, according to their families,.... Which was allotted to it and divided, according to the number of its families: these cities with their villages; before enumerated, excepting such as only bordered on them; though indeed there were other cities which belonged to them, or might be after given them, not here mentioned, as Kartah and Dimnah, Jos 21:34.”

Joshua 19:17-23

the fourth lot came out: Issachar is given by its towns rather than a traced border, because the tribe sits enclosed between portions already described. Jezreel at verse 18 becomes the second royal city of Israel and the ground of Naboth's vineyard at 1 Kings 21:1. Shunem is where the Philistines camp before Saul's last night at 1 Samuel 28:4, and where the woman who kept a room for Elisha lived at 2 Kings 4:8.

Joshua 19:17

“The fourth lot came out to Issachar - It is remarkable, that though Issachar was the eldest brother, yet the lot of Zebulun was drawn before his lot; and this is the order in which Jacob himself mentions them, Gen 49:13, Gen 49:14, though no reason appears, either here or in the place above, why this preference should be given to the younger; but that the apparently fortuitous lot should have distinguished them just as the prophetic Jacob did, is peculiarly remarkable.”

Barnes calls Jezreel and its plain the choicest part of Issachar's inheritance. Gill places Chesulloth south of Mount Tabor and Chisloth-tabor of verse 12 north of it, treating them as two places. Abishag of 1 Kings 1:3 was a Shunammite.

Jamieson, Fausset and Brown place the towns of verses 18-20 in the eastern part of the plain of Esdraelon. Gill, following Jerome, sets Hapharaim six miles north of Legio and Shion near Mount Tabor. Anaharath occurs only here.

Gill reports the view of Masius that Kishion gave its name to the river Kishon. That river swept away the enemy at Judges 5:21, and Elijah killed the prophets of Baal beside it at 1 Kings 18:40. Kishion itself goes to the Levites at 21:28.

Barnes renders En-gannim fountain of gardens and identifies it with Jenin, where the road from Jerusalem enters the plain of Jezreel. It returns among the Levite towns at 21:29, beside Jarmuth, which Gill takes as Remeth. Many places in these verses remain unknown, Barnes adds.

The border ends here at the Jordan, and Barnes suggests Tabor means the town on the mountain, the Levite town listed at 1 Chronicles 6:77. Clarke counts several towns named Beth-shemesh, house of the sun, as evidence of sun worship in Canaan. Barnes keeps this one apart from Judah's at 15:10.

Joshua 19:22

“And the coast reacheth to Tabor,.... Tabor was the name of a mountain in those parts; it is generally supposed to be the mountain on which our Lord was transfigured, though it is not sufficiently evident; See Gill on Jer 46:18. There was a city of this name near it, 1Ch 6:77, and which is meant here, and which either gave unto or received name from the mount.”

1 more voice on this verse

Joshua 19:22

“Beth-shemesh - The house or temple of the sun; there were several cities or towns of this name in Palestine; an ample proof that the worship of this celestial luminary had generally prevailed in that idolatrous country.”

Issachar's portion is summed up here. Jacob's blessing at Genesis 49:15 has Issachar seeing that its land was pleasant and bending its shoulder to labor. Its men in David's day understood the times, according to 1 Chronicles 12:32.

Joshua 19:23

“This is the inheritance of the tribe of the children of Issachar,.... Which fell to them by lot, as before described: according to their families; was divided among them, according to the number of them: the cities and their villages; the cities before enumerated, and the villages adjacent to them.”

Asher and Naphtali, from the sea to the hills

Joshua 19:24-31

the fifth lot came out: Asher's border runs past Carmel as far as "Greater Sidon" and "the fortified city of Tyre", ground Israel never held. Judges 1:31 names towns Asher did not drive out, and Sidon, Rehob, Achzib and Aphek all stand in this allotment. Keil and Delitzsch read Joshua as the record of land granted rather than land occupied, and Matthew Henry lays the shortfall on Israel's own slackness rather than on the promise.

Joshua 19:24

“And the fifth lot came out for the tribe of the children of Asher,.... Which entitled them to an inheritance next described: according to their families; which was sufficient for them, and divided to them according to their number.”

Barnes places Helkath about seven or eight miles north-west of Acre, and it returns as a Levite town at 21:31. Achshaph sent its king to Jabin's northern league at 11:1, and his defeat is counted at 12:20. Gill sets Beten eight miles east of Ptolemais.

Joshua 19:25

“And their border was Helkath,.... Helkath seems to be the same with Hukok, 1Ch 6:75; and according to Masius it lay ten or twelve miles above Ptolemais: and Hali, of which we read nowhere else. and Beten is by Jerom (h) called Bathne, and was in his time a village by the name of Bethebem, eight miles from Ptolemais to the east.”

1 more voice on this verse

Joshua 19:25

“Helkath, a Levitical town Jos 21:31, is probably Yerka, a village about seven or eight miles north-west of Acre, in a Wady of the same name. Alammelech was in the “Wady Melik,” which joins the Kishon from the northeast, not far from the sea. Shihor-libnath - i. e. “black-white.” The two words are now generally admitted to be the name of a river, probably the modern “Nahr Zerka,” or Blue River, which reaches the sea about 8 miles south of Dor, and whose name has a correspondence both to black and white.”

Carmel on the western edge is the mountain where Elijah met the prophets of Baal at 1 Kings 18:19-40, as Clarke notes. Barnes reads Shihor-libnath, black and white, as a river reaching the sea south of Dor. Dor lay inside Asher's ground and went to Manasseh, by 17:11.

Joshua 19:26

“Carmel - The vineyard of God; a place greatly celebrated in Scripture, and especially for the miracles of Elijah; see 1 Kings 18:19-40. The mountain of Carmel was so very fruitful as to pass into a proverb. There was another Carmel in the tribe of Judah, (see Jos 15:55), but this, in the tribe of Asher, was situated about one hundred and twenty furlongs south from Ptolemais, on the edge of the Mediterranean Sea. Calmet observes that there was, in the time of Vespasian, a temple on this mountain, dedicated to a god of the same name.”

1 more voice on this verse

Joshua 19:26

“Carmel west-ward - Or, Carmel by the sea, to distinguish it from Carmel in the tribe of Judah. This was a place of eminent fruitfulness, agreeable to the prophecy concerning Asher, Gen. xlix, 20.”

John Wesley · Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical

The whole record on this verse →

Wesley and Clarke explain on the left as north, since a man giving directions faced east. Cabul returns at 1 Kings 9:13, where Hiram of Tyre calls the Galilean towns Solomon gave him the Land of Cabul. A second Beth-dagon stands in Judah's list at 15:41.

Joshua 19:27

“Cabul on the left hand - That is, to the north of Cabul, for so the left hand, when referring to place, is understood among the Hebrews.”

Barnes describes these towns as the northern part of Asher on the Phoenician frontier. Wesley explains Greater Sidon as a title for the city's age and wealth, and places this Kanah in upper Galilee. Genesis 10:15 names Sidon the firstborn of Canaan.

Joshua 19:28

“Unto great Zidon - The city of Sidon and the Sidonians are celebrated from the remotest antiquity. They are frequently mentioned by Homer. See the note on Jos 11:8.”

1 more voice on this verse

Joshua 19:28

“Kenah - Namely, Kenah the greater, in the upper Galilee; not Kenah the less, which was in the lower Galilee. Zidon - Called great for its antiquity, and riches, and glory.”

John Wesley · Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical

The whole record on this verse →

Wesley reads the line as running up to Tyre and excluding it, since the city formed no part of the grant. He and Jamieson, Fausset and Brown both place this Tyre on the mainland, apart from the island city of later history. David's palace was built with Tyrian cedar at 2 Samuel 5:11.

Joshua 19:29

“The strong city Tyre - I suspect this to be an improper translation. Perhaps the words of the original should be retained: And the coast turneth to Ramah and to the city, מבצר צר mibtsar tsor. Our translators have here left the Hebrew, and followed the Septuagint and Vulgate, a fault of which they are sometimes guilty. The former render the place ἑως πολεως οχυρωματος των Τυριων, unto the fortified city of the Tyrians.”

1 more voice on this verse

Joshua 19:29

“To Tyre - Exclusively, for this city was no part of the land given them. But this was not the same city we read of afterwards. For that was built on an island, this on the continent.”

John Wesley · Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical

The whole record on this verse →

Clarke counts nearly thirty names against the total of twenty-two. He explains the difference as frontier towns the border passed by without taking in, and Gill reads it the same way. Ummah occurs nowhere else, Gill notes.

Joshua 19:30

“Twenty and two cities - There are nearly thirty cities in the above enumeration instead of twenty-two, but probably several are mentioned that were but frontier towns, and that did not belong to this tribe, their border only passing by such cities; and on this account, though they are named, yet they do not enter into the enumeration in this place. Perhaps some of the villages are named as well as the cities.”

Asher's portion is summed up along the northern coast. Gill calls it a very fruitful country, answering Jacob's word over Asher's food at Genesis 49:20. Deborah's song at Judges 5:17 records that Asher stayed at the coast while others fought.

Joshua 19:31

“This is the inheritance of the tribe of the children of Asher,.... As before described, a goodly heritage; it was, according to the prediction of Jacob and Moses, Gen 49:20; a very fruitful country.”

Joshua 19:32-39

The sixth lot came out: Hazor, burned as the head of the northern kingdoms at 11:10-11, appears at verse 36 as an ordinary town, yet by Judges 4:2 a king reigning in Hazor oppresses Israel again. Kedesh at verse 37 becomes a city of refuge at 20:7 and is where Deborah sends for Barak at Judges 4:6. Judges 1:33 names Beth-shemesh and Beth-anath as towns Naphtali never cleared, and both close this list.

Joshua 19:32

“It was in the lot of this tribe, near the waters of Merom, that Joshua fought and routed Jabin, ch. xi. In this tribe stood Capernaum and Bethsaida, on the north end of the sea of Tiberias, in which Christ did so many mighty works; and the mountain (as is supposed) on which Christ preached, Matt. v. 1 .”

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

Wesley reads this as Naphtali's northern border, drawn from west to east until it meets the Jordan. Heber the Kenite pitched his tent by the great tree of Zaanannim near Kedesh at Judges 4:11, and Sisera fled to that tent at Judges 4:17. Barnes renders Adami-nekeb as Adami of the pass.

Joshua 19:33

“From Allon to Zaanannim - Render “from the oak forest at Zaanannim.” From Jdg 4:11 it appears that this oak or oak-forest was near Kedesh. Adami, Nekeb - Render “Adami of the Pass.” Possibly the ancient “Deir el Ahmar” (“red cloister”), which derives its name from the color of the soil in the neighborhood, as perhaps Adami did. The spot lies about 8 miles northwest of Baalbek.”

The phrase Judah at the Jordan is a known difficulty, since several tribes lay between Naphtali and Judah, as Clarke points out. Barnes explains it by the towns of Jair across the river, whose line ran back to Judah through Hezron at 1 Chronicles 2:21-22. Clarke leaves the problem unsettled.

Joshua 19:34

“And to Judah upon Jordan - It is certain that the tribe of Naphtali did not border on the east upon Judah, for there were several tribes betwixt them. Some think that as these two tribes were bounded by Jordan on the east, they might be considered as in some sort conjoined, because of the easy passage to each other by means of the river; but this might be said of several other tribes as well as of these.”

Barnes reads Naphtali's many fortified cities as a belt of defence on the northern frontier, matching Judah's fortresses in the south. He takes Hammath from a root meaning warm and places it by hot springs near Tiberias. Numbers 34:11 names the Sea of Chinnereth after it.

Joshua 19:35

“The number of the fortified cities of Naphtali is remarkable, though it does not tally with the catalogue. It was no doubt good policy to protect the northern frontier by a belt of fortresses, as the south was protected by the fenced cities of Judah. Hammath, a Levitical city (compare Jos 21:32; 1Ch 6:76), is not to be confounded with the Hamath on the northeastern frontier of the land Num 13:21. The name (from a root signifying “to be warm”) probably indicates that hot springs existed here; and is perhaps rightly traced in Ammaus, near Tiberias.”

Gill keeps Adamah apart from the Adami of verse 33 and notes that several towns were called Ramah, from their height. Hazor, burned at 11:11, appears again at 1 Kings 9:15. Solomon built it up there with Megiddo and Gezer.

Gill distinguishes this Edrei from the Edrei in Bashan where Og met Israel in battle at Numbers 21:33, and finds En-hazor nowhere else. Kedesh and Hazor both fell to Tiglath-pileser of Assyria at 2 Kings 15:29. That verse records the people of Naphtali carried to Assyria.

Clarke counts twenty-three names against the total of nineteen and again explains the surplus as frontier towns that only marked the border. The same gap appears in Asher's list at verse 30. Barnes keeps this Beth-shemesh apart from the towns of that name in Judah and Issachar.

Joshua 19:38

“Nineteen cities - But if these cities be separately enumerated they amount to twenty-three; this is probably occasioned by reckoning frontier cities belonging to other tribes, which are only mentioned here as the boundaries of the tribe. See on Jos 19:30 (note).”

Josephus, as Gill quotes him, gives Naphtali upper Galilee as far as Lebanon and the springs of the Jordan. Matthew Henry places Capernaum and Bethsaida within this tribe, towns where many of Christ's miracles were done according to Matthew 11:21-23. Henry adds that Joshua routed Jabin here at 11:5-7.

Joshua 19:39

“This is the inheritance of the tribe of the children of Naphtali,.... Which Josephus (o) thus describes;"the country to the east, as far as Damascus the city, and upper Galilee, the Naphtalites took, unto Mount Lebanon, and the fountains of Jordan, which flow out of the mount, reaching the northern border of the city Arce:" according to their families; which was divided among them, according to the number of their families: the cities and their villages; before enumerated. (o) Antiqu. l. 5. c. 1. sect. 22.”

Dan's lot lost and refought; Joshua's own town last

Joshua 19:40-46

the seventh lot came out: Dan draws last and is set down on the Philistine edge, between Judah and the sea. Zorah and Eshtaol open the list at verse 41, the towns of Samson's birth at Judges 13:2, of the Spirit's first moving at Judges 13:25 and of his burial at Judges 16:31. Ekron at verse 43 was already written into Judah at 15:45 and remains Philistine all through the books of Samuel.

Joshua 19:40

“And the seventh lot came out for the tribe of the children of Dan,.... Which was the last lot drawn, and which appointed an inheritance to this tribe: according to their families; the number of them.”

Wesley observes that Dan is given by its towns alone, because much of its ground came out of Judah's large portion and shares Judah's lines. Zorah and Eshtaol already stand in Judah's foothill list at 15:33-34. Clarke notes a view that Ir-shemesh, city of the sun, is Beth-shemesh.

Joshua 19:41

“Zorah, and Eshtaol - See the note on Jos 15:33. Ir-shemesh - The city of sun; another proof of the idolatry of the Canaanites. Some think this was the same as Beth-shemesh.”

1 more voice on this verse

Joshua 19:41

“Of their inheritance - Which is here described only by its cities, not its borders, which are in part the same with Judah's, and their inheritance is in good part taken out of Judah's too large portion; as appears from divers of the cities here mentioned, which are also reckoned in Judah's portion.”

John Wesley · Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical

Aijalon lies in the valley over which the moon stood still at 10:12, as Gill recalls. Clarke renders Shaalabbin the foxes, and Gill finds Ithlah nowhere else. Rehoboam fortified Aijalon, according to 2 Chronicles 11:10.

Joshua 19:42

“Shaalabbin - The foxes. Of this city the Amorites kept constant possession. See Jdg 1:35. Ajalon - There was a place of this name about two miles from Nicopolis or Emmaus, on the road to Jerusalem. - Calmet.”

Clarke joins this Timnah to a Timnah of Judah, while Gill keeps the two apart. Samson went down to a Timnah and saw a Philistine woman there at Judges 14:1. Ekron received the captured ark at 1 Samuel 5:10.

Eltekeh and Gibbethon both go to the Levites from Dan at 21:23. Gibbethon was still a Philistine town when Baasha killed Nadab there during a siege at 1 Kings 15:27. Solomon later built a Baalath, listed at 1 Kings 9:18.

Clarke reads Jehud and Bene-berak as one place, Jehud of the sons of Berak. Gill renders Bene-berak sons of lightning and notes its later fame among the Jews as the home of a noted rabbi. Gath-rimmon goes to the Levites at 21:24.

This strip carried Dan's lot to the coast, and Barnes calls Joppa the leading port of access to Jerusalem. Log rafts from Lebanon reached Joppa at 2 Chronicles 2:16. Jonah sailed from there at Jonah 1:3, and Peter raised Tabitha there at Acts 9:36-41.

Joshua 19:47-48

Two verses tell a move that Judges 18 tells over thirty-one. Judges 1:34 gives the pressure behind the loss, the Amorites forcing Dan into the hill country, and Judges 18:29 calls the town Laish and ends on the same renaming after Dan their father. This chapter leaves out what Judges puts at the centre: the graven image the tribe carried north and the priesthood that served there until the captivity.

Joshua 19:47

“The words “too little” are an insertion of the King James Version Render rather, “the border of the children of Dan was extended.” The Hebrew appears to mean “the children of Dan enlarged their border because they had not room enough.” The reason of this was that the Danites, a numerous tribe (Num 26:5 note), found themselves Jdg 1:34-35 cooped up among the hills by the powerful and warlike Amorites.”

Gill fixes Dan between Ephraim on the north, Judah on the east, Simeon on the south and the sea on the west. Jamieson, Fausset and Brown add that its ground came from Judah and Ephraim both. Verse 47 shows the tribe losing this ground.

Joshua 19:48

“This is the inheritance of the tribe of the children of Dan,.... Before described by its cities, which were in it. This tribe was bounded by Ephraim on the north, by Judah on the east, by Simeon on the south, and by the Mediterranean sea on the west.”

Joshua 19:49-51

Joshua is served last, after every tribe has its portion, and receives his town by the people's gift "as the LORD had commanded", the same ground on which Caleb received Hebron at 14:13. So the two men who brought back the good report in Numbers 14 stand at the head of the allotment and at its close. Joshua is buried at Timnath-serah at 24:30, called Timnath-heres at Judges 2:9.

Joshua 19:49

“The children of Israel - That is, they are said to give it, because the whole land was given to Joshua, and Eleazar, and the princes, as joint trustees, acting in the name, and for the good of the people: so that even Joshua could take nothing without their gift.”

John Wesley · Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical

Wesley reads rebuilt as repaired and enlarged, the sense in which Nebuchadnezzar claims to have built Babylon at Daniel 4:30. Barnes suggests the name Timnath-serah means the portion that remains, fitting the last grant of the whole division. Clarke calls it a barren spot.

Joshua 19:50

“Timnath-serah - Called Timnath-heres in Jdg 2:9, where we find that the mountain on which it was built was called Gaash. It is generally allowed to have been a barren spot in a barren country.”

3 more voices on this verse

Joshua 19:50

“The word of The Lord - As God had promised, or commanded; either formerly, or at this time by Eleazar. He built - That is, repaired and enlarged it, in which sense Nebuchadnezzar is said to have built Babylon, Dan. iv, 30.”

John Wesley · Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical

Joshua 19:50

“And indeed we said above that even our Lord Jesus Christ asks us for a place he may build and in which he may live and that we ought to become so clean of heart, and so sincere of mind, so holy in body and spirit, that he may both deign to accept this place in our soul and to build it and dwell in it. And who do you think among all the people are so acceptable to God that they are worthy to be chosen for this?”

Origen of Alexandria · written before 253 · HOMILIES ON JOSHUA 26.1patristic

Joshua 19:50

“But the gift was not left to the spontaneous feelings of a grateful people. It was conferred "according to the word of the Lord"--probably an unrecorded promise, similar to what had been made to Caleb (Jos 14:9).”

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown · Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

The three authorities named here match the commission of Numbers 34:17-18, which appointed Eleazar, Joshua and a leader from each tribe to divide the land. The same three open the distribution at 14:1. Jamieson, Fausset and Brown read the verse as the formal close of the whole account.

Joshua 19:51

“At the door of the tabernacle - All the inheritances were determined by lot, and this was cast before the Lord - every thing was done in his immediate presence, as under his eye; hence there was no murmuring, each having received his inheritance as from the hand of God himself, though some of them thought they must have additional territory, because of the great increase of their families.”

How this psalm is built

The form: Six allotment records in one chapter, each opened by its lot number, and closed by a single grant to Joshua, as Keil and Delitzsch classes it.

The patterns in this chapter

The devices this chapter is built on, what each one does, and one verse where it stands.
DeviceWhat it doesWhere to see it
The lot counted off, six timesEach tribe's section opens with its number. The second lot falls at verse 1, the third at verse 10, the fourth at verse 17, the fifth at verse 24, the sixth at verse 32 and the seventh at verse 40. The counting runs on from Benjamin's first lot at Joshua 18:11, so the seven lots of chapter 18 and chapter 19 are one series.Keil and Delitzsch, Biblical Commentary on the Old Testament: Joshua, Judges, Ruth, 1863, on Joshua 19.Joshua 19:1, Joshua 19:10, Joshua 19:17, Joshua 19:24, Joshua 19:32, Joshua 19:40
The closing formula on every portionFive of the six sections close with the same sentence, that this was the inheritance of the clans of the tribe, at verses 8, 16, 23, 31, 39 and 48. The formula seals each portion and makes the chapter readable as six separate records.John Gill, Exposition of the Old Testament, 1748 to 1763, on Joshua 19.Joshua 19:16, Joshua 19:23, Joshua 19:31, Joshua 19:39, Joshua 19:48
The towns given and the towns keptAsher's list at verses 24 to 31 names Sidon, Rehob, Achzib and Aphek, and Judges 1:31 names those same four among the places Asher did not drive out. The allotment and the failure share their vocabulary.Keil and Delitzsch, Biblical Commentary on the Old Testament: Joshua, Judges, Ruth, 1863, on Joshua 19:24 to 31.Joshua 19:28, Joshua 19:29, Joshua 19:30
The last tribe served first and the leader served lastThe division opened at Joshua 18:1 with the whole congregation at Shiloh and closes at verse 51 at Shiloh before the LORD at the door of the tent of meeting. Between those two points every tribe is served, and Joshua receives his own town only at verse 50, after them all.Matthew Henry, Commentary on the Whole Bible, 1708 to 1710, on Joshua 19:49 to 51.Joshua 19:49, Joshua 19:50, Joshua 19:51

The structure

12 more paragraphs on the patterns

Seven units. Six lots at verses 1 to 48, then the grant to Joshua at verses 49 to 51. The lot numbers run second through seventh, continuing the count from Benjamin at Joshua 18:11.

Three sections give a border and three give a list, and the difference follows the shape of the ground. Zebulun, Asher and Naphtali have traced lines. Simeon, Issachar and Dan are given as towns.

The chapter closes where chapter 18 opened it, at Shiloh before the LORD at the entrance to the tent of meeting.

Across the canon

Ziklag at verse 5 is already listed to Judah at Joshua 15:31, and Achish hands it to David at 1 Samuel 27:6.

Gath-hepher at verse 13 is the home town of Jonah son of Amittai, named as such at 2 Kings 14:25, so a boundary list fixes where a prophet came from. The Bethlehem of verse 15 sits in Galilee and is a different town from the Bethlehem of Judah at Micah 5:2.

Jezreel at verse 18 becomes the ground of Naboth's vineyard at 1 Kings 21:1. Shunem in the same verse is where the Philistines camp before Saul's last night at 1 Samuel 28:4 and where the woman who kept a room for Elisha lived at 2 Kings 4:8.

Hazor at verse 36 was the head of the northern kingdoms and was burned at Joshua 11:10 and 11. It appears here as an ordinary town, and a king of Hazor is oppressing Israel again by Judges 4:2. Kedesh at verse 37 is set apart as a city of refuge at Joshua 20:7 and is where Deborah sends for Barak at Judges 4:6.

Zorah and Eshtaol at verse 41 are where Samson is born at Judges 13:2, where the Spirit of the LORD first moves him at Judges 13:25, and where he is buried at Judges 16:31.

Timnath-serah at verse 50 is where Joshua is buried at Joshua 24:30, and Judges 2:9 records the name as Timnath-heres.

In the New Testament

Isaiah 9:1 speaks over the land of Zebulun and the land of Naphtali, the two portions given at verses 10 to 16 and 32 to 39 of this chapter. Matthew 4:15 quotes that verse of Christ settling in Capernaum, so two of the six lots cast here are named in the Gospel as the ground where the preaching began.

Keep studying

Sources for this chapter

The summary

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown, Commentary Critical and Explanatory; John Calvin, Commentaries; John Wesley, Notes on the Old Testament and Matthew Henry, Complete Commentary.

The form and classifications

Keil and Delitzsch and Matthew Henry, Commentary on the Whole Bible, 1708 to 1710, on Joshua 19:24 to 31.

The exposition

Adam Clarke, Commentary on the Bible; Albert Barnes; Jamieson, Fausset & Brown, Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible; John Calvin, Commentaries; John Gill; John Wesley, Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament; Keil and Delitzsch, Biblical Commentary on the Old Testament: Joshua, Judges, Ruth; Matthew Henry, Commentary on the Whole Bible and The Berean Standard Bible, Joshua 19, with the verses cited in the note.