Skip to content
mannafest.faith
Scripture: The text alone. Study: The verses explained. Original: The Hebrew and Greek, and the tradition.

Genesischapter 40

23 verses · Moses, by tradition · 15th to 13th century BC · The Law

Some time later, the king’s cupbearer and baker offended their master, the king of Egypt.

Introduction

Moses, by tradition, The Law, Genesis Overview.

This chapter keeps Joseph in the king's prison, and Israel heard it as a lesson in waiting on God. Two officials of Pharaoh's household are put in his care, and the chapter turns on what they see in the night. Egyptians took dreams seriously and kept trained men to read them. Listen for what Joseph says about where the meaning of a dream comes from, and for how closely the two dreams mirror each other. Notice the one request Joseph makes for himself. The chapter ends on a delay, and his rise waits for the next one.

Context

Who
Israel in the wilderness, learning that God speaks in a jail as readily as in a palace
What
A narrative of Joseph interpreting the dreams of Pharaoh's cupbearer and baker in prison, and of the cupbearer forgetting him.
Where
The prison in the house of the captain of the guard in Egypt, where the king's prisoners were held.
When
About 1889 to 1887 BC on the traditional chronology, two years before Joseph stands before Pharaoh.
Why
To show that the meaning of dreams belongs to God, and to set up the delay before Joseph is brought to Pharaoh.

Historical context

The chapter belongs to two officers of Pharaoh's household and to the prisoner assigned to attend them, so Joseph is a convict serving other convicts. The time is the last stretch of his imprisonment, which 41:1 measures by the two full years that follow it, and the place is the prison attached to the captain of the guard's house.

Show the rest of the historical context, 3 more paragraphs

The occasion is a pair of dreams on one night and their readings. The chief cupbearer tasted and served the king's wine and stood as close to the throne as anyone in Egypt, and part of his duty was to guard against poison. The chief baker ran the palace bakeries. John D. Currid records both as titled positions in the Egyptian records.

What a first hearer understood at once is how an Egyptian prison worked. Men under royal displeasure were held pending a decision rather than serving a sentence, they were assigned a keeper, and other prisoners could be set to attend them, which is Joseph's job at verse 4.

The verdict comes on Pharaoh's birthday, the occasion for a review of cases and the kind of amnesty a king was expected to grant. One officer is restored and the other is hanged on a tree after execution, which denied him the burial an Egyptian needed for the afterlife.

Significance

Joseph reads both dreams exactly right and the chapter ends with the cupbearer forgetting him for two more years.

Show the rest of the significance, 1 more paragraph

Israel, whose own deliverance came four centuries after the promise, knew that arithmetic from the inside.

This chapter in Jewish lifeWhat this chapter is in Jewish life and reading.

How it is read

Rashi links the two chapters by the woman's slander: the officers fell so that Egypt would have something else to talk about than Joseph (Rashi on Genesis 40:1:1, the Pentateuch with Rashi's commentary by M. Rosenbaum and A. M. Silbermann, 1929 to 1934, public domain). For the offences of the butler and the baker he hands on the midrash's small and exact answer: "in the case of the one, a fly was found in the goblet of aromatic wine, in the case of the other, a pebble was found in the loaves he baked", on Genesis Rabbah 88:2 (Rashi on Genesis 40:1:2). The three branches and the three baskets he reads as counters rather than as periods, "They are a symbol to you of three days", and notes that the rabbis read them in several ways at Chullin 92a (Rashi on Genesis 40:12:1). The lifting of the head he explains from the idiom for counting: "When he musters his other servants to wait upon him during the meal he will count you also among them" (Rashi on Genesis 40:13:1). On the baker's baskets he describes what he knew himself, "In our country there are many such baskets and sellers of fancy rolls" put their wares in them (Rashi on Genesis 40:16:1), and on Pharaoh's birthday he gives the Hebrew form a reason, "because the infant is born only by the assistance of others", and names the day as the birthday festival on the authority of Avodah Zarah 10a (Rashi on Genesis 40:20:1). Radak reads the chapter as a study in how a prisoner treats other prisoners. He says the Torah names the two men as Pharaoh's officials although they were then no better placed than Joseph, and that "When Joseph saw their pitiful state of mind" he asked after them (Radak on Genesis 40:7:1, translated by Eliyahu Munk, HaChut Hameshulash, CC-BY), and he reads the baker's dream by the perishable goods in it (Radak on Genesis 40:18:1). Ibn Ezra comments here at six places and the corpus holds no English of him under a licence permitting quotation, so he stands as a citation: Ibn Ezra on Genesis 40:2:1, 40:3:1, 40:8:1, 40:15:1, 40:19:1 and 40:21:1.

What the rabbis say

The corpus records forty rabbinic locators on this chapter, thirty-four of them Midrash and six Talmud. Midrash Lekach Tov is the densest work here, cited at Genesis 40:4:1, 40:4:2, 40:6:1, 40:6:2, 40:7:1, 40:8:1, 40:21:1 and 40:23:1 and at Esther 2:21:3, which is the one place in this chapter where the rabbis read the two officers against the two doorkeepers of Esther. Bereshit Rabbah is cited at 19:2, 87:10, 88:1, 88:2, 88:4, 88:5, 88:7, 89:2 and 89:3, Bereshit Rabbati at Parashat Vayeshev 34, 35, 36, 51 and 52, Midrash Aggadah at Genesis 40:8:1, 40:9:1, 40:12:1, 40:17:1 and 40:17:2, and Bamidbar Rabbah at 1:11, 11:7, 14:5 and 15:12. The six Talmud locators fall where the chapter is about dreams and about the reading of them: Berakhot 55b and 55b:18 on dreaming and on the dream that is interpreted, Chullin 92a:5 and 92a:13 at the vine and the pressing of the cup, Jerusalem Talmud Pesachim 10:1:7 at the cup itself, and Jerusalem Talmud Avodah Zarah 1:2:9 at Pharaoh's birthday. Rashi hands on further sayings with their locators, among them Genesis Rabbah 88:2, Chullin 92a and Avodah Zarah 10a.

Sources: Rashi, Rashi on Genesis 40:1:1, 40:1:2, 40:4:1, 40:5:1, 40:6:1, 40:10:1, 40:11:1, 40:12:1, 40:13:1, 40:14:1, 40:16:1, 40:20:1 and 40:23:1, the Pentateuch with Rashi's commentary by M. Rosenbaum and A. M. Silbermann, 1929 to 1934, public domain; Radak, Radak on Genesis 40:2:1, 40:7:1, 40:9:1, 40:17:1 and 40:18:1, translated by Eliyahu Munk, HaChut Hameshulash, CC-BY; Ibn Ezra, Ibn Ezra on Genesis 40:2:1, 40:3:1, 40:8:1, 40:15:1, 40:19:1 and 40:21:1, cited only, no English version in the corpus under a licence permitting quotation; Midrash, Midrash Lekach Tov, Genesis 40:4:1, 40:4:2, 40:6:1, 40:6:2, 40:7:1, 40:8:1, 40:21:1 and 40:23:1 and Midrash Lekach Tov on Esther 2:21:3; Bereshit Rabbah 19:2, 87:10, 88:1, 88:2, 88:4, 88:5, 88:7, 89:2 and 89:3; Bereshit Rabbati, Parashat Vayeshev 34, 35, 36, 51 and 52; Midrash Aggadah, Genesis 40:8:1, 40:9:1, 40:12:1, 40:17:1 and 40:17:2; Bamidbar Rabbah 1:11, 11:7, 14:5 and 15:12; Devarim Rabbah 2:8; Midrash Sekhel Tov, Bereshit 40:12:1; Ein Yaakov (Glick Edition), Shabbat 23:6; Babylonian Talmud, Berakhot 55b and 55b:18, Chullin 92a:5 and 92a:13; Chullin 92a and Avodah Zarah 10a as Rashi cites them; Jerusalem Talmud, Jerusalem Talmud Pesachim 10:1:7, Jerusalem Talmud Avodah Zarah 1:2:9.

The heads below are this chapter's scenes. The numbered points under each are its verses.

Two Troubled Dreams in Prison

Genesis 40:1-3

the king’s cupbearer and baker offended their master: Two of Pharaoh's officers offend him and land in the same prison where Joseph is held. They are the chief cupbearer and the chief baker, men who served the king at his own table. Henry's line on it is that high places are slippery places and nothing is less certain than the favour of princes. The prison sits inside the captain of the guard's house.

Genesis 40:1

“The world stands for the sake of the church, and is governed for its good. Two of the great officers of Pharaoh's court, having offended the king, are committed to prison. Note, High places are slippery places; nothing more uncertain than the favour of princes.”

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

1 more voice on this verseWhat preachers and commentators have said about this verse, in their own words.

Genesis 40:1

“Both officers, especially the former, were, in ancient Egypt, always persons of great rank and importance; and from the confidential nature of their employment, as well as their access to the royal presence, they were generally the highest nobles or princes of the blood.”

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown · Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

The whole record on this verse →

Pharaoh was angry with his two officers: Officers is saris in Hebrew, a court title. Each man is the chief of a staff, one over the king's wine and one over his bread. Nehemiah later held the office of cupbearer to the king of Persia, according to Nehemiah 1:11.

the same prison where Joseph was confined: Confined is asur in Hebrew, bound, the word for a prisoner in fetters, and Psalm 105:20 answers it when the king sends and releases him. Two men from Pharaoh's own table now sit in Joseph's prison. Two years later one of them carries his name to Pharaoh.

Genesis 40:3

“Where Joseph was bound - The place in which Joseph was now confined; this is what is implied in being bound; for, without doubt, he had his personal liberty. As the butler and. the baker were state criminals they were put in the same prison with Joseph, which we learn from the preceding chapter, Gen 39:20, was the king’s prison.”

1 more voice on this verse

Genesis 40:3

“Pharaoh put them in ward, &c.--Whatever was their crime, they were committed, until their case could be investigated, to the custody of the captain of the guard, that is, Potiphar, in an outer part of whose house the royal prison was situated.”

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown · Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

assigned them to Joseph: The captain of the guard assigns two of Pharaoh's officers to a man in his own prison. Jamieson takes that captain to be Potiphar himself, the master who jailed him now trusting him with officers of the crown. The phrase behind some time is days, and Clarke reports the older reckoning of a full year. Pharaoh calls the two to account on his next birthday.

Genesis 40:4

“The captain of the guard charged Joseph with them--not the keeper, though he was most favorably disposed; but Potiphar himself, who, it would seem, was by this time satisfied of the perfect innocence of the young Hebrew; though, probably, to prevent the exposure of his family, he deemed it prudent to detain him in confinement (see Ps 37:5).”

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown · Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

1 more voice on this verse

Genesis 40:4

“They continued a season - ימים yamim, literally days; how long we cannot tell. But many suppose the word signifies a complete year; and as Pharaoh called them to an account on his birthday, Gen 40:20, Calmet supposes they had offended on the preceding birthday, and thus had been one whole year in prison.”

The whole record on this verse →

Genesis 40:5-7

Two men dream on the same night, and each carries a meaning of its own. Clarke reads both as dreams with an interpretation waiting in them. Joseph comes in the morning, sees that they are distraught, and asks why their faces are downcast. He is the one man in Genesis whose own dreams nobody ever interprets for him.

Genesis 40:5

“Each man according to the interpretation - Not like dreams in general, the disordered workings of the mind, the consequence of disease or repletion; these were dreams that had an interpretation, that is, that were prophetic.”

he saw that they were distraught: Joseph comes in the morning on his rounds, the work the warden gave him at Genesis 39:22. Distraught renders a Hebrew word for men troubled and dejected, and he sees it on two faces. His own wrong leaves him quick to see another man's grief.

Genesis 40:6

“And Joseph came in unto them in the morning,.... For though Joseph and they were in the same prison, yet not in the same ward.”

2 more voices on this verse

Genesis 40:6

“They were sad - They concluded that their dreams portended something of great importance, but they could not tell what.”

Genesis 40:6

“Note, God has more ways than one to sadden the spirits of those that are to be made sad. Those sinners that are hardy enough under outward troubles, and will not yield to them, yet God can find out a way to punish; he can take off their wheels, by wounding their spirits, and laying loads upon them.”

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

The Hebrew question is why are your faces bad today, and a king asks his cupbearer nearly the same words at Nehemiah 2:2. Both times the question opens the way to a king's favor.

Genesis 40:7

“This remarkable man, however, concerned for their comfort, noticed that they were dismayed by the experience of the dreams and confused in mind; so he asked, "Why so downcast today?" The dejection on their faces, you see, betrayed the apprehension within them. Hence a sage too has said, "When the heart is free from care, the face beams, but when it is in mourning the face falls." So, when he saw them lost in dejection from the experience of their dreams, he questioned them to discover the cause.”

John Chrysostom · written before 407 · HOMILIES ON GENESIS 63.4patristic

1 more voice on this verse

Genesis 40:7

“It is some relief to those that are in trouble to be taken notice of. To enquire into the causes of our own sorrow, "Wherefore do I look so sadly? Is there not a reason for comfort sufficient to balance it, whatever it is?”

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

Egypt was full of men paid to interpret dreams, and these two in a cell can reach none of them. Joseph hands the credit away before anyone offers it to him, and Henry sets that beside Daniel doing the same before Nebuchadnezzar. Interpretations belong to God is his answer. He asks for the dreams after he has said whose the answers are.

Genesis 40:8

“Joseph premises a caveat against his own praise, and is careful to transmit the glory to God, as Daniel, ch. ii. Joseph suggests, "If interpretations belong to God, he is a free agent, and may communicate the power to whom he pleases, and therefore tell me your dreams." Now, 1.”

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

1 more voice on this verse

Genesis 40:8

“There is no interpreter - They either had access to none, or those to whom they applied could give them no consistent, satisfactory meaning. Do not interpretations belong to God? - God alone, the Supreme Being, knows what is in futurity; and if he have sent a significant dream, he alone can give the solution.”

The Cup and the Basket Explained

Genesis 40:9-11

there was a vine before me: The cupbearer dreams his own day's work, a vine with three branches, grapes, and the cup of Pharaoh. Clarke notes that the juice is pressed straight from the grape into the cup with no fermenting, which is how the office was done. Jamieson adds that the cup rested on the fingertips. Nothing in the picture is strange to the man dreaming it, and what he lacks is the count of days.

on the vine were three branches: The vine buds, blossoms and ripens in a single sentence, a whole season passing in moments. The speed fits the answer Joseph gives, restoration within three days. Egyptian tomb paintings at Thebes show vineyards, grape treading and wine jars.

squeezed them into his cup: The Hebrew names Pharaoh three times in this one verse, his cup twice and his hand once. Squeezed renders sachat, a verb found only here in the Old Testament. Joseph's own silver cup later tests his brothers at Genesis 44:2.

Genesis 40:11

“And I took the grapes and pressed them into Pharaoh’s cup - From this we find that wine anciently was the mere expressed juice of the grape, without fermentation. The saky, or cup-bearer, took the bunch, pressed the juice into the cup, and instantly delivered it into the hands of his master. This was anciently the יין yain of the Hebrews, the οινος of the Greeks, and the mustum of the ancient Latins.”

1 more voice on this verse

Genesis 40:11

“Everything was done in the king's presence--the cup was washed, the juice of the grapes pressed into it; and it was then handed to him--not grasped; but lightly resting on the tips of the fingers.”

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown · Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

Genesis 40:12-13

The three branches are three days: Gill points out that three branches would serve as well for three months or three years, so the reading is given to Joseph. He tells the cupbearer that Pharaoh will lift up his head within three days and restore his position. The cup goes back into Pharaoh's hand the way it always did. The same phrase about the head returns six verses on.

Genesis 40:12

“And Joseph said unto him, this is the interpretation of it,.... Of the dream: the three branches are three days; signify three days, or, as Jarchi expresses it, are a sign of three days; which Joseph could know only by divine revelation; for there is no more likeness between branches and days, than between them and months or years, and bid as fair to signify one as the other, if the interpretation depended on similarity, or bare conjecture.”

Pharaoh will lift up your head: The Hebrew of 2 Kings 25:27 uses the same phrase when the king of Babylon releases Jehoiachin from prison. Numbers 1:2 uses the idiom for taking a census, calling a man up to be counted. Pharaoh will call the cupbearer up by name.

Genesis 40:13

“I do not wish to speak of someone else's dream. You certainly remember my words, that even then I refused to interpret it because I fear its outcome, the death that I dread. Let us first speak of the man who, when he was in charge of wine, seemed to be happy and believed that this was the pinnacle of power because he gave the cup to the king. This was his glory, this was his magnificence in this world, and he grieved being deprived of it; he rejoiced when it was restored to him.”

Ambrose of Milan · written before 397 · On Joseph the Patriarchpatristic

Genesis 40:14-15

please remember me: This is the only thing Joseph asks of anyone. He asks the cupbearer to remember him to Pharaoh and get him out of the prison. The word behind remember is the one Genesis uses when God remembered Noah at 8:1 and remembered Rachel at 30:22. Wesley notes that Joseph says only that he was kidnapped, taken from the land of the Hebrews.

Genesis 40:14

“Therefore, consider that Hebrew saying to the eunuch, who had incurred the wrath of the king, whom he had restored to his position: Remember yourself, when you are doing well, and show mercy towards me, and remember me. He repeated it a second time, because he knew that he would not recall what had happened once he regained his power.”

Ambrose of Milan · written before 397 · On Joseph the Patriarchpatristic

1 more voice on this verse

Genesis 40:14

“Nothing has hitherto met us in the record indicative of Joseph's feelings; but this earnest appeal reveals a sadness and impatient longing for release, which not all his piety and faith in God could dispel.”

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown · Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

The whole record on this verse →

I was kidnapped from the land of the Hebrews: Kidnapped is a doubled verb in Hebrew, stolen, yes stolen. The word for dungeon is bor, the pit of Genesis 37:24, so this prison and his first prison share a name. The land of the Hebrews is a name for Canaan used in this verse alone.

Genesis 40:15

“He doth not reflect upon his brethren that sold him, only saith, I was stolen out of the land of the Hebrews. Nor doth he reflect on the wrong done him in this imprisonment by his mistress that was his persecutor, and his master that was his judge, but mildly avers his own innocency.”

John Wesley · Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical

1 more voice on this verse

Genesis 40:15

“For indeed I was stolen - גנב גנבתי gunnob gunnobti, stolen, I have been stolen - most assuredly I was stolen; and here also have I done nothing. These were simple assertions, into the proof of which he was ready to enter if called on.”

The whole record on this verse →

Genesis 40:16-17

the interpretation was favorable: The baker speaks only after he hears a favorable answer. His dream keeps the three, and the baskets sit on his head while birds eat out of the top one. Jamieson notes that birds were held sacred in Egypt and could not lawfully be killed, so a man who let them settle would feel the dread of it. Jerome records that where the Greek had three baskets of wheat, the Hebrew gives three measures of meal.

the birds were eating them out of the basket: In the cupbearer's dream the service reaches Pharaoh's hand, and in this dream the king's food goes to the birds. Abram drove the birds of prey away from his offering at Genesis 15:11. The baker lets them eat.

Genesis 40:17

“The risk from these carnivorous birds was the greater in the cities of Egypt, where being held sacred, it was unlawful to destroy them; and they swarmed in such numbers as to be a great annoyance to the people. Joseph answered and said, This is the interpretation--The purport was that in three days his execution should be ordered.”

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown · Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

Genesis 40:18-19

The three baskets are three days: Joseph gives the true reading when the true reading is a death sentence. Pharaoh will lift off the head this time, and the body goes on a tree for the birds. Clarke notes that Egyptian practice beheaded the man first and hung the body after, so the two halves belong to one sentence. The word that restored the cupbearer condemns the baker.

Genesis 40:18

“And Joseph answered and said,.... Immediately, directly, without any further thought and meditation, being divinely instructed: this is the interpretation thereof; of the above dream: the three baskets are three days; signify three days.”

1 more voice on this verse

Genesis 40:18

“Thus hypocrites, when they hear good things promised to good Christians, would put in for a share, though they have no part nor lot in the matter. It was not Joseph's fault that he brought him no better tidings. Ministers are but interpreters, they cannot make the thing otherwise than it is; if therefore they deal faithfully, and their message prove unpleasing, it is not their fault.”

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

hang you on a tree: Egyptians set great weight on the burial of the body, and a body left for the birds to eat its flesh was denied it. The law at Deuteronomy 21:22 to 23 ordered a hanged body taken down before night. Paul applies that verse to Christ at Galatians 3:13.

Genesis 40:19

“Lift up thy head from off thee - Thus we find that beheading, hanging, and gibbeting, were modes of punishment among the ancient Egyptians; but the criminal was beheaded before he was hanged, and then either hanged on hooks, or by the hands. See Lam 5:12.”

The Butler Forgets Joseph

Genesis 40:20-22

which was Pharaoh’s birthday: Both readings come true on the third day, when the feast lifts up the heads of both men, one to his office and the other to a tree. Clarke notes the first birthday feast in Scripture, and the only other the Bible reports is Herod's. Gill passes on a Jewish tradition that the cupbearer was cleared of a plot to poison Pharaoh and the baker held guilty.

Genesis 40:20

“Pharaoh’s birthday - The distinguishing a birthday by a feast appears from this place to have been a very ancient custom. It probably had its origin from a correct notion of the immortality of the soul, as the commencement of life must appear of great consequence to that person who believed he was to live for ever. St. Matthew (Mat 14:6) mentions Herod’s keeping his birthday; and examples of this kind are frequent to the present time in most nations.”

Pharaoh restored the chief cupbearer to his position: The cupbearer takes up the office he held before, and the dream is fulfilled to the letter. At Genesis 41:9 to 13 he tells Pharaoh this very outcome, his own restoration and the baker's hanging. The fulfilled dream becomes Joseph's reference.

Genesis 40:21

“And he restored the chief butler unto his butlership again,.... Put him into the same office he was in before: and he gave the cup into Pharaoh's hand; ministered to him in his office the same day, according to his dream and the interpretation of it: the Targum of Jonathan adds this as a reason of his being restored,"because he found that he was not in that counsel,''in which it was consulted to poison Pharaoh; see Gill on Gen 40:1.”

But Pharaoh hanged the chief baker: Deuteronomy 18:22 later gives the test of a prophet's word, whether it comes true. Joseph's two readings pass that test within three days. Pharaoh's own dreams at Genesis 41 are the next test.

Genesis 40:22

“But he hanged the chief baker,.... The is, he ordered him to be hanged; because, as the same Targum says, he consulted to kill him (Pharaoh): as Joseph had interpreted to them; the events as to both answered to the interpretation Joseph had given of their several dreams.”

he forgot all about him: The verse says it twice, that the cupbearer did not remember Joseph and that he forgot all about him. The word is the one Joseph used when he asked to be remembered, and it is the word that fails him. The cupbearer goes back to Pharaoh's cup. Joseph stays in the prison.

Genesis 40:23

“Yet did not the chief butler remember Joseph - Had he mentioned the circumstance to Pharaoh, there is no doubt that Joseph’s case would have been examined into, and he would in consequence have been restored to his liberty; but, owing to the ingratitude of the chief butler, he was left two years longer in prison. Many commentators have seen in every circumstance in the history of Joseph a parallel between him and our blessed Lord.”

1 more voice on this verse

Genesis 40:23

“Joseph's fellow-sufferers were like the two thieves that were crucified with Christ--the one saved, the other condemned. (It is Dr. Lightfoot's remark, from Mr. Broughton.) One of these, when Joseph said to him, Remember me when it shall be well with thee, forget him; but one of those, when he said to Christ, Remember me when thou comest into thy kingdom, was not forgotten.”

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

The whole record on this verse →

How this psalm is built

The form: Narrative, the prison episode, recorded because it served Joseph's preferment, as Wesley classes it.

The patterns in this chapter

The devices this chapter is built on, what each one does, and one verse where it stands.
DeviceWhat it doesWhere to see it
Lift up the head, said three times in seven versesVerse 13 has Pharaoh lifting up the cupbearer's head to restore him, verse 19 has him lifting off the baker's head to hang him, and verse 20 lifts up the heads of both men on the same day, counted in the Berean text in the store. Adam Clarke records that Egyptian practice beheaded the criminal first and hung the body after, so the two sentences are one phrase with two ends.Adam Clarke, Commentary on the Bible, 1832, on Genesis 40:19.Genesis 40:13, Genesis 40:19, Genesis 40:20
The three and the threeThe cupbearer's vine has three branches and the baker's head carries three baskets, and Joseph reads both as three days. John Gill points out that three branches would serve as well for three months or three years, so the count of days is given to Joseph rather than drawn from the picture.John Gill, Exposition of the Old Testament, 1748 to 1763, on Genesis 40:12.Genesis 40:10, Genesis 40:12, Genesis 40:16, Genesis 40:18
Remember me, and he did not rememberThe one thing Joseph asks of any man in this book is at verse 14, that the cupbearer remember him. Verse 23 answers it twice over, that the chief cupbearer did not remember Joseph and that he forgot all about him. Adam Clarke reads the silence as ingratitude and reckons that a word to Pharaoh would have had the case examined and Joseph released.Adam Clarke, Commentary on the Bible, 1832, on Genesis 40:23.Genesis 40:14, Genesis 40:23
Do not interpretations belong to GodJoseph answers the two men at verse 8 with a question that hands the skill away before he uses it. Matthew Henry notes that he enters a caveat against his own praise and sets the line beside Daniel in Babylon at Daniel 2, where the trained readers also fail and a captive answers the king.Matthew Henry, Commentary on the Whole Bible, 1710, on Genesis 40:8.Genesis 40:8

How the rest of Scripture reads this chapter

8 more paragraphs on the patterns

Matthew Henry reads the two prisoners beside the two men crucified with Christ, the one saved and the other condemned, and he credits the comparison to Dr. Lightfoot from Mr. Broughton. The point turns on one word. Joseph says remember me when it goes well for you and the cupbearer forgets him, and the thief at Luke 23:42 says remember me when You come into Your kingdom and is answered that day.

Adam Clarke observes that this is the first birthday feast recorded in Scripture and names the one other the Bible reports, Herod's at Matthew 14:6, which also ends with a head taken off.

The debated concept

How long the two officers waited is disputed. Verse 4 says in the Berean text that they were in custody for some time, and Adam Clarke reports that the Hebrew word is days and that many read it as a full year, which Calmet fixed by Pharaoh's birthday at verse 20 as the anniversary of their offence. John Gill allows about a week, a month or a year.

Who the captain of the guard is at verse 3 is a second question. Jamieson, Fausset and Brown take him to be Potiphar himself, by this time satisfied of Joseph's innocence and keeping him in confinement to spare his household the exposure. John Gill allows the same identification and adds two other possibilities, that Potiphar had died or that more than one man held the office.

The offence itself the text does not give. Adam Clarke supposes an attempt on the king's life, one by his drink and the other by his bread, which would explain why both table officers fell together. John Gill reports the Targum of Jonathan to the same effect and has the baker consulting to kill Pharaoh and the cupbearer cleared of the plot.

The divine connection

The chapter gives two predictions with a date on them and reports both outcomes three days later, one restoration and one execution, which is the plainest test of a prophetic reading the book has offered so far. Joseph claims nothing for himself in making them and says at verse 8 that interpretations belong to God. Genesis 41:32 states the rule the chapter has already shown, that a matter settled by God is carried out shortly, and Joseph will read Pharaoh's doubled dream by it.

Keep studying

Sources for this chapter

The summary

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown, Commentary Critical and Explanatory; John Calvin, Commentaries; John Wesley, Notes on the Old Testament and Matthew Henry, Complete Commentary.

The form and classifications

Adam Clarke, Commentary on the Bible, 1832, on Genesis 40:5; Jamieson, Fausset & Brown, Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible, 1871, on Genesis 40:1; John Wesley, Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament, 1765, on Genesis 40:1 and Matthew Henry, Commentary on the Whole Bible, 1710, on Genesis 40:1.

The exposition

Adam Clarke, Commentary on the Bible; Chuck Missler, The Book of Genesis; Jamieson, Fausset & Brown, Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible; Jerome, Hebrew Questions on Genesis; John Calvin, Commentary on Genesis; John Gill, Exposition of the Old Testament; John Wesley, Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament; Keil and Delitzsch, Biblical Commentary on the Old Testament and Matthew Henry, Commentary on the Whole Bible.