Skip to content
mannafest.faith

Matthew 15:5

But you say that if anyone says to his father or mother, ‘Whatever you would have received from me is a gift devoted to God,’

BSB

Parallel translations (2) ▾

ASV

But ye say, Whosoever shall say to his father or his mother, That wherewith thou mightest have been profited by me is given to God;

KJV

But ye say, Whosoever shall say to his father or his mother, It is a gift, by whatsoever thou mightest be profited by me;

Commentary

4 voices

Voices on this verse

loading…

Hebraic traditional view

Handwashing, korban, and which tradition weighs more

“Why do thy disciples transgress the tradition of the elders? for they wash not their hands when they eat bread.” The washing in question is netilat yadayim, a ritual pouring of water over the hands before eating bread. It was never about hygiene: it extends to the ordinary table the purity washing the Torah requires of priests before they eat holy food, one more piece of the Pharisaic program to make every table an altar. The Mishnah devotes a whole tractate to it (Yadayim 1:1 opens with the required quantity of water), and observant homes keep the practice before bread to this day.

Jesus answers with a harder case from the same tradition: korban. Property declared korban (“an offering”) was barred from ordinary use as if dedicated to God, and the vow formula could be used to lock a son's goods away from his own parents; the Mishnah records the substitute formulas people spoke (Nedarim 1:2). Jesus weighs that vow against the commandment “honor thy father and mother” and rules that no vow can cancel it. The tradition itself wrestled with the same tension: its vow-release discussions include a debated question about opening a release by appeal to the parents' honor (Nedarim 9:1 records the rabbis divided over exactly that move). Jesus' ruling cuts where the tradition circled.

Sources: Mishnah Yadayim 1:1 (the handwashing rite) · Mishnah Nedarim 1:2 (the korban formulas) · Mishnah Nedarim 9:1 (release of vows and the parents' honor, a recorded dispute)

Original language & word study

17 tagged words
OriginalTransliterationMeaningWord study
ὑμεῖςhumeisYou yourselvesG4771
δὲdehoweverG1161
λέγετε·legetesay;G3004
ὃςhosWho[ever]G3739
ἂνanmaybeG302
εἴπῃeipēmay sayG2036
τῷto theG3588
πατρὶpatrifatherG3962
ēorG2228
τῇtēatheG3588
μητρί·mētrimother;G3384
δῶρονdōron[It is] a giftG1435
howhateverG3739
ἐὰνeanifG1437
ἐξexbyG1537
ἐμοῦemoumeG1473
ὠφεληθῇς,ōphelēthēasyou shall be profited,G5623

The walk

About Matthew

John the Baptist Baptizes Jesus — Gustave Doré (engraving, public domain)
John the Baptist Baptizes Jesus — Gustave Doré (engraving, public domain)