Skip to content
mannafest.faith
Scripture: The text alone. Study: The verses explained. Original: The Hebrew and Greek, and the tradition.

Jonahchapter 4

11 verses · Jonah, by tradition · 8th century BC · The Twelve

Key verse

But it displeased Jonah exceedingly, and he was very angry.

It stands in Angry enough to die: I knew you were a gracious God, verses 1 to 4.

The chapter

Chapter summary

The revival that delights heaven infuriates the preacher. Jonah's prayer finally admits why he ran: 'I knew that thou art a gracious God, and merciful, slow to anger, and abundant in lovingkindness' (the Exodus 34 creed quoted as an accusation) followed by 'take, I beseech thee, my life from me.' God asks, 'Doest thou well to be angry?' then teaches by object lesson: a prepared gourd for shade, a prepared worm that kills it, a prepared sultry east wind. Jonah pities the plant he did not grow. God's closing question ends the book unanswered: should not I have regard for that great city, and its sixscore thousand who cannot discern their right hand from their left?

Context

Prophecy · Jonah · Jonah overview

The world behind this chapter

Jonah 4
When
After the city was spared · Early to mid eighth century BC, immediately after chapter 3
Where
A shelter Jonah built on a hill east of Nineveh, waiting to see what would happen
Who first heard it
A nation being asked whether it wanted God's mercy to have limits

The history

Jonah finally explains why he ran, and it is not fear. He says he knew all along that God is gracious and merciful, slow to anger and of great kindness, and repents of the evil, which is a direct quotation of how God described Himself to Moses at Sinai. Jonah ran because he believed the creed and did not want it applied to Assyria.

The rest of the history, and what it meant to them

He builds a booth on the east side of the city and sits in it. The shelter would be branches over a frame, the same kind of temporary hut used at harvest and at the Feast of Tabernacles, enough for shade, not enough for a hot wind.

The plant that grows over him is called a qiqayon, often identified with the castor-oil plant, which grows fast, has broad leaves, and can wilt overnight if the stem is damaged. A worm at the stem would do it.

The east wind that follows is the sirocco off the desert: dry, dust-laden, and brutally hot, a wind that regularly makes people ill in that region. Jonah, with no shade and that wind, asks to die.

God's closing question includes a number: more than 120,000 people who cannot discern between their right hand and their left, most naturally read as young children, which would put the wider population much higher, "and also much cattle." God's last recorded words in the book mention the livestock.

What it meant to them

The book ends on a question, unanswered. That is deliberate; the reader has to answer it.

For Israel, the point was that they had a God whose compassion ran past their borders and past their enemies' record, and that this was not a flaw in Him. Jonah cared more about a plant he did not grow than about a city of people. The prophet's anger, not Nineveh's wickedness, is the last thing the book examines.

Sources cited

Every work MannaFest builds on →

Where the chapter sits

Jonah 4 falls in The complaint (chapters 4). ‘I knew that thou art a gracious God’ (4:2). The gourd, the worm, the east wind; the LORD's question that closes the book unanswered.

The complaint. ‘Doest thou well to be angry?’ The book's closing question.

Before it: The preaching, chapters 3.

The whole shape of Jonah

The structure of this chapter

The heads below are this chapter's scenes. The numbered points under each are its verses.

A. Angry enough to die: I knew you were a gracious God

1. (vv. 1-3)

Jonah 4:1

"But it displeased Jonah exceedingly and he was very angry. [And he prayed unto the LORD, and said]" LXX: 'Jonah was saddened by a great sadness, and he was confounded. And he prayed to the Lord, and he said'. Seeing the crowd of gentiles enter [Rom. 11:25], and that fulfils what is written in Deuteronomy: "they annoyed me with these gods who are not gods, so I will annoy them with a people that is not one; I shall anger them like a foolish nation" [Deut. 32:21].

Jerome· written before 420· Commentary on Jonah, Chapter 4patristic

2 more voices on this verseWhat preachers and commentators have said about this verse, in their own words.

Jonah 4:1

And Jonah was displeased exceedingly - It was an untempered zeal. The prophet himself records it as such, and how he was reproved for it. He would, like many of us, govern God’s world better than God Himself. Short-sighted and presumptuous! Yet not more short-sighted than those who, in fact, quarrel with God’s Providence, the existence of evil, the baffling of good, “the prison walls of obstacles and trials,” in what we would do for God’s glory. What is all discontent, but anger with God?

Jonah 4:1

Jonah was grieved because Nineveh's preservation, after his denunciation, made him seem a false prophet [CALVIN]. But it would make Jonah a demon, not a man, to have preferred the destruction of six hundred thousand men rather than that his prophecy should be set aside through God's mercy triumphing over judgment.

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown· Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

The whole record on this verse

Jonah 4:2

And he prayed unto the Lord - Jonah, at least, did not murmur or complain of God. He complained to God of Himself. He expostulates with Him. Shortsighted indeed and too wedded to his own will! Yet his will was the well-being of the people whose prophet God had made him. He tells God, that this it was, which he had all along dreaded. He softens it, as well as he can, by his word, “I pray Thee,” which expresses deprecation anti-submissiveness. Still he does not hesitate to tell God that this was the cause of his first rebellion!

1 more voice on this verse

Jonah 4:2

Being in discontent, he applied to the duty of prayer, as he used to do in his troubles, but his corruptions got head of his graces, and, when he should have been praying for benefit by the mercy of God himself, he was complaining of the benefit others had by that mercy.

Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

The whole record on this verse

Jonah 4:3

Such a word as this may be the language of grace, as it was in Paul, who desired to depart and be with Christ, which is far better; but here it was the language of folly, and passion, and strong corruption; and so much the worse, [1.] Jonah being now in the midst of his usefulness, and therefore fit to live.

Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

1 more voice on this verse

Jonah 4:3

Jonah's impatience of life under disappointed hopes of Israel's reformation through the destruction of Nineveh, is like that of Elijah at his plan for reforming Israel (1Ki 18:1-46) failing through Jezebel (1Ki 19:4).

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown· Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

The whole record on this verse

But it displeased Jonah exceedingly: Jonah's anger erupts the moment mercy is confirmed: Nineveh spared displeases him exceedingly, and he asks the Lord to take his life rather than let him live to see it stand. His prayer names the reason he fled to Tarshish in the first place, quoting back to God his own self-description, a gracious God, and merciful, slow to anger, and of great kindness, and repentest thee of the evil, the same formula the Lord proclaimed of himself at Sinai. Jonah preached judgment and got mercy, and the prophet who ran from that mercy for Nineveh now begs to die rather than watch it stand. Calvin reads the prayer as Jonah's confession turned complaint, the truth about God's character used as an accusation against God's own kindness.

2. (v. 4)

Jonah 4:4

Then said the Lord, dost thou well to be angry? A mild and gentle reproof this; which shows him to be a God gracious and merciful, and slow to anger; he might have answered Jonah's passionate wish, and struck him dead at once, as Ananias and Sapphira were; but he only puts this question, and leaves it with him to consider of. Some render it, "is doing good displeasing to thee?" (y) art thou angry at that, because I do good to whom I will? so R.

3 more voices on this verse

Jonah 4:4

"Then said the LORD, Do you well to be angry?" LXX: 'The Lord replied to Jonah, are you so much afflicted?' The Hebrew word hara lach can be translated as 'are you annoyed?' and are you afflicted?'. And each one pertains to the prophet and to the Lord: either he is annoyed and fears appearing a liar to the inhabitants of Nineveh, or he is afflicted, knowing that Israel is going to be destroyed.

Jerome· written before 420· Commentary on Jonah, Chapter 4patristic

Jonah 4:4

Doest thou well to be angry? - ההיטב הרה לך haheitib harah lac, “Is anger good for thee?” No, anger is good for no man; but an angry preacher, minister, bishop, or prophet, is an abominable man. He who, in denouncing the word of God against sinners, joins his own passions with the Divine threatenings, is a cruel and bad man, and should not be an overseer in God’s house. A surly bishop, a peevish, passionate preacher, will bring neither glory to God, nor good to man.

Jonah 4:4

Doest thou well to be angry?--or grieved; rather as the Margin, "Art thou much angry," or "grieved?" [FAIRBAIRN with the Septuagint and Syriac]. But English Version suits the spirit of the passage, and is quite tenable in the Hebrew [GESENIUS].

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown· Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

The whole record on this verse

Jonah 4:4-6

Doest thou well to be angry?: The Lord's question doest thou well to be angry receives no answer; Jonah instead walks out of the city, builds a booth on its east side, and sits watching to see what will become of Nineveh, still hoping for the fire he preached. The Lord God prepares a gourd, most likely the qiqayon plant identified with the fast growing castor plant or with a true gourd vine, the readings named without settling which, to shade Jonah's head from his grief. Jonah's gladness over one plant's shade sets up the argument the Lord will make from the small mercy to the great one. Clarke and Jamieson, Fausset and Brown both note that Jonah's grief here is not for Nineveh's souls but for his own vindication as a prophet of judgment.

B. A gourd, a worm, and a scorching east wind

1. (vv. 5-6)

Jonah 4:5

So Jonah went out of the city - o, The form of the words implies (as in the English Version), that this took place after Jonah was convinced that God would spare Nineveh; and since there is no intimation that he knew it by revelation, then it was probably after the 40 days . “The days being now past, after which it was time that the things foretold should be accomplished, and His anger as yet taking no effect, Jonah understood that God had pity on Nineveh.

2 more voices on this verse

Jonah 4:5

The forty days were now expiring, or had expired, and Jonah hoped that, if Nineveh was not overthrown, yet some judgement or other would come upon it, sufficient to save his credit; however, it was with great uneasiness that he waited the issue.

Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

Jonah 4:5

Therefore, not from sullennesss, but in order to watch the event from a neighboring station, he lodged in the booth. As a stranger, he did not know the depth of Nineveh's repentance; besides, from the Old Testament standpoint he knew that chastening judgments often followed, as in David's case (2Sa 12:10-12, 14), even where sin had been repented of.

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown· Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

The whole record on this verse

Jonah 4:6

And the Lord God prepared a gourd - I believe this should be rendered in the preterpluperfect tense. The Lord Had prepared this plant, קיקיון kikayon. It had in the course of God’s providence been planted and grown up in that place, though perhaps not yet in full leaf; and Jonah made that his tent. And its thick branches and large leaves made it an ample shelter for him, and because it was such, he rejoiced greatly on the account. But what was the kikayon?

1 more voice on this verse

Jonah 4:6

It was a shadow over his head, to deliver him from his grief, that, being refreshed in body, he might the better guard against the uneasiness of his mind, which outward crosses and troubles are often the occasion and increase of. See how tender God is of his people in their afflictions, yea, though they are foolish and froward, nor is he extreme to mark what they do amiss.

Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

The whole record on this verse

2. (vv. 7-8)

Jonah 4:7

A small worm at the root destroys a large gourd. So it takes but little to make our creature comforts wither. It should silence discontent to remember, that when our gourd is gone, our God is not gone. the next day--after Jonah was so "exceeding glad" (compare Ps 80:7).

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown· Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

1 more voice on this verse

Jonah 4:7

When the morning rose - , i. e., in the earliest dawn, before the actual sunrise. For one day Jonah enjoyed the refreshment of the palm-christ. In early dawn, it still promised the shadow; just ere it was most needed, at God’s command, it withered.

The whole record on this verse

Jonah 4:8

And it came to pass when the sun did arise,.... After that the gourd was smitten and withered; when it was not only risen, but shone out with great force and heat: that God prepared a vehement east wind; or, "a deafening east wind" (u); which blew so strong, and so loud, as R.

2 more voices on this verse

Jonah 4:8

A vehement east wind - Which was of itself of a parching, withering nature; and the sun, in addition, made it intolerable. These winds are both scorching and suffocating in the East, for deserts of burning sand lay to the east or south-east; and the easterly winds often brought such a multitude of minute particles of sand on their wings, as to add greatly to the mischief. I believe these, and the sands they carry, are the cause of the ophthalmia which prevails so much both in Egypt and India.

Jonah 4:8

Jonah had said, I do well to be angry, but he could not prove it. God says and proves it, I do well to be merciful; and it is a great encouragement to poor sinners to hope that they shall find mercy with him, that he is so ready to justify himself in showing mercy and to triumph in those whom he makes the monuments of it, against those whose eye is evil because his is good.

Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

The whole record on this verse

But God prepared a worm: The same verb that prepared the great fish at 1:17 now prepares a worm to smite the gourd and a vehement east wind to beat on Jonah's head, fish, plant, worm, and wind each arranged by God's own hand to teach the prophet rather than to punish Nineveh. Jonah faints under the sun and repeats his death wish in the same words he used at verse 3, it is better for me to die than to live, the plant's loss undoing him more than a spared city ever did. Keil reads the sequence as deliberate escalation, comfort given and then instruction given by comfort withdrawn. Wesley notes the east wind was the sirocco known across the region for its choking heat, no unusual weather invented where a known wind will do.

C. Should I not spare a city of 120,000 and much cattle?

1. (v. 9)

Jonah 4:9

"And God said to Jonah, Do you well to be angry for the gourd? And he said, I do well to be angry, even unto death." LXX: 'and the Lord God said to Jonah, are you so afflicted for a gourd? He replied, 'I am very afflicted even to the point of death'. When he was asked about the repentance of the inhabitants of Nineveh and the safety of the city of the gentiles, 'do you well to be angry?', the prophet replied nothing, yet justified God's question by his silence.

Jerome· written before 420· Commentary on Jonah, Chapter 4patristic

4 more voices on this verse

Jonah 4:9

And God said to Jonah, dost thou well to be angry for the gourd?.... Or, "art thou very angry for it?" as the Targum: no mention is made of the blustering wind and scorching sun, because the gourd or plant raised up over him would have protected him from the injuries of both, had it continued; and it was for the loss of that that Jonah was so displeased, and in such a passion.

Jonah 4:9

Doest thou well to be angry? - o “See again how Almighty God, out of His boundless lovingkindness, with the yearning tenderness of a father, almost disporteth with the guileless souls of the saints! The palm-christ shades him: the prophet rejoices in it exceedingly. Then, in God’s Providence, the caterpillar attacks it, the burning East wind smites it, showing at the same time how very necessary the relief of its shade, that the prophet might be the more grieved, when deprived of such a good. He asketh him skillfully, was he very grieved? and that for a shrub?

Jonah 4:9

Sin and death are two very dreadful things, yet Jonah, in his heat, makes light of them both. He has so little regard for God as to fly in the face of his authority, and to say that he did well in that which God said was ill done. Passion often over-rules conscience, and forces it, when it is appealed to, to give a false judgment, as Jonah here did.

Matthew Henry· Commentary on the Whole Bible (1707-1721)puritan

Jonah 4:9

But even this was not an unmitigated evil. Jonah was a type, as of Christ, so also of Israel. Jonah, though an outcast, was highly honored of God in Nineveh; so Israel's outcast condition would prove no impediment to her serving God's cause still, if only she was faithful to God.

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown· Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible (1871)reformed

Doest thou well to be angry for the gourd?: The Lord repeats his question, narrowed now to the gourd alone, and Jonah answers without a trace of repentance, I do well to be angry, even unto death, defending his anger over a dead plant with the same words he used to defend his anger over a spared city. Barnes reads the repetition of the question as pastoral patience, God meeting Jonah's temper a second time rather than rebuking it outright. Pusey notes the irony the text leaves for the reader to see for himself, Jonah will grieve a plant that cost him no labor while begrudging the mercy shown to a city of thousands, the very disproportion the closing verses expose.

2. (vv. 10-11)

Jonah 4:10

"Then said the LORD, You have had pity on the gourd, for the which you have not laboured, neither made it grow; which came up in a night, and perished in a night: and should not I spare Nineveh, that great city, wherein are more than sixscore thousand persons that cannot discern between their right hand and their left hand; and also much cattle?" LXX: 'and the Lord said, 'you wanted to keep safe a gourd which has done you no wickedness, that you have not cared for, which was born in one night and died in one night.

Jerome· written before 420· Commentary on Jonah, Chapter 4patristic

1 more voice on this verse

Jonah 4:10

Which came up in a night - St. Jerome, speaking of this plant, the kikayon, assigns to it an extraordinary rapidity of growth. It delights in a sandy soil, and in a few days what was a plant grows into a large shrub. But he does not appear to have meant the ricinus; this however is the most likely.

The whole record on this verse

Jonah 4:11

That great city - Wouldest thou have me less merciful to such a goodly city, than thou art to a weed? Who cannot discern - Here are more than six-score innocents who are infants. Much cattle - Beside men, women and children who are in Nineveh, there are many other of my creatures that are not sinful, and my tender mercies are and shall be over all my works.

John Wesley· Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament (1765)evangelical

2 more voices on this verse

Jonah 4:11

Should I not spare? - literally “have pity” and so “spare.” God waives for the time the fact of the repentance of Nineveh, and speaks of those on whom man must have pity, those who never had any share in its guilt, the 120,000 children of Nineveh, “I who, in the weakness of infancy, knew not which hand, “the right” or “the left,” is the stronger and fitter for every use.” He who would have spared Sodom “for ten’s sake,” might well be thought to spare Nineveh for the 120,000’s sake, in whom the inborn corruption had not developed into the malice of willful sin.

Jonah 4:11

On the following day the Book of Jonah was read according to custom, after the completion of which I began this discourse. A book has been read, brethren, in which it is foretold that sinners shall be converted. Their acceptance takes place because that which is to happen is looked forward to at present. I added that the just man had been willing even to incur blame, in order not to see or denounce the destruction of the city.

Ambrose of Milan· written before 397· Letters, Epistle 20patristic

The whole record on this verse

Thou hast had pity on the gourd: The Lord's closing argument moves from the lesser to the greater: Jonah pitied a gourd he did not plant, did not tend, and lost within a single night, so should not the Lord pity Nineveh, that great city, where more than sixscore thousand persons cannot discern their right hand from their left, besides much cattle. The commentators read the sixscore thousand two ways, the whole population reckoned as morally undiscerning like children, or the number naming Nineveh's infants specifically, and both readings are named without settling between them. The book ends without recording Jonah's answer, the Lord's question left standing as the last word, mercy wider than the prophet who preached it. Gill and Calvin both read the unanswered question as address to every reader who has ever sat in Jonah's booth wanting judgment more than mercy for someone else.

This page carries no textual note on Jonah 4. Where this site has examined a place the manuscripts differ, the examination is in the manuscripts room. Every place this site examines →

Sources for this chapter

The summary

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown, Commentary Critical and Explanatory; John Calvin, Commentaries; John Wesley, Notes on the Old Testament and Matthew Henry, Complete Commentary.

The exposition

Adam Clarke, Commentary on the Bible; Albert Barnes, Notes on the Old Testament; Carl Friedrich Keil, The Twelve Minor Prophets; Edward Bouverie Pusey, The Minor Prophets: A Commentary; Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown, Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible; John Calvin, Commentaries on the Twelve Minor Prophets; John Gill, Exposition of the Old Testament; John Wesley, Explanatory Notes upon the Old Testament and Matthew Henry, Commentary on the Whole Bible.

Keep studying