Skip to content
mannafest.faith
Portrait of Bonaventure
Fra Angelico · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

The Great Cloud of Witnesses · The Long Middle

Bonaventure

died 1274Patristic

He led the Franciscans through a civil war of their own and mapped the mind's journey up into God.

Summary

Bonaventure lived died 1274. This wing places Bonaventure in The Long Middle, AD 600–1500.
  • Lived died 1274.
  • Stood in The Long Middle (AD 600–1500).
  • Hangs on The Fathers.
  • Tradition: Patristic / Western.

The life

He was born Giovanni di Fidanza at Bagnoregio in central Italy, about 1217. The story he tells is that he was gravely ill as a small child and his mother prayed to Francis of Assisi for him, and he recovered. He went to Paris to study, joined the Franciscans around 1243, and studied theology under Alexander of Hales.

He was teaching at Paris in the 1250s alongside Thomas Aquinas, the two friars, a Dominican and a Franciscan, at the same university at the same moment, both under attack from the secular masters who wanted the mendicant orders thrown out of the schools. They were admitted as full masters on the same day in 1257. By then Bonaventure had already been elected Minister General of the Franciscan order, at about forty.

The order was tearing itself apart. Francis had died in 1226 leaving a movement committed to absolute poverty. One party, the Spirituals, held that the founder's rule must be kept literally, no property, no buildings, no books. The other wanted an order that could run schools, staff parishes, and own the roof over its head. Both sides claimed Francis.

Bonaventure spent seventeen years holding it together. He legislated, travelled constantly, deposed his radical predecessor's supporters, and wrote an official life of Francis, the Legenda Maior, that was so carefully balanced the general chapter of 1266 ordered all earlier lives destroyed so that his would stand alone. That order was an act of governance, and it cost the church some early sources.

His theology went the other direction from Aquinas. Where Thomas built out from Aristotle, Bonaventure stayed with Augustine and with the Victorines, and insisted that the point of learning is love. His most famous work, The Journey of the Mind into God, was written in 1259 on Mount La Verna, where Francis had received the stigmata. It maps the ascent in six stages, from seeing God through the created world, to seeing him in the image of the soul, to contemplation above the mind, and ends by saying that at the summit the intellect must fall silent and only love goes further.

He also wrote the Breviloquium, a compact summary of theology, the Collations on the Six Days, and a commentary on Peter Lombard's Sentences.

He was made cardinal bishop of Albano in 1273, the legend says the envoys found him washing dishes and had to wait, and did much of the work of the Second Council of Lyons, which briefly reunited the Greek and Latin churches. He died during the council, on 15 July 1274, four months after Aquinas.

Sources: Bonaventure, The Journey of the Mind into God, Breviloquium, and Legenda Maior; Philip Schaff, History of the Christian Church, vol. V; The Catholic Encyclopedia (1913); The Little Flowers of St. Francis.

What was happening while he lived2 moments · AD 600–1500
  1. 1209Francis of Assisi and the friarsA rich young man from Assisi takes Jesus' words to the twelve literally, gives up everything, and goes preaching in a patched robe. Innocent III approves his little band around 1209–1210. Whatever came of the order later, its first fire was real: the gospel carried on foot to people the parish system had stopped reaching.
  2. 1274Thomas Aquinas dies with his great work unfinishedThe most influential theologian of the medieval West dies on March 7 at about forty-nine. The traditional account says that months earlier, after an experience during Mass, he stopped writing and said that all he had written seemed like straw. His *Summa Theologiae* ends mid-argument.

The Long Middle: the whole era

In their own words

  • Do not fear those who kill the body and after this have nothing more that they can do; but I will show you whom you should fear: fear him who, after he has killed, has power to cast into gehenna." I would prefer to be …

    Collationes de Septem Donis, Collation 2 · on Hebrews 10:31

    It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God.

  • A promissory oath is made for preserving fidelity, and this is done in three ways, namely for restraining malice, for settling controversy, and for clearing away infamy. First, it is made for restraining malice, so that a man may neither deny the true nor affirm …

    Collationes de Decem Praeceptis, Collation 3 · on Hebrews 6:16

    Men swear by someone greater than themselves, and their oath serves as a confirmation to end all argument.

  • As for the inciting causes, it is added: Who had come to hear him, as regards the illumination of truth in the mind, and to be healed of their infirmities, as regards the cure of health in the flesh. And this was a right intention, …

    Commentary on Luke, Chapter 6 · on Luke 6:18

    They had come to hear Him and to be healed of their diseases, and those troubled by unclean spirits were healed.

Go further

Read them yourself. Public-domain works are free to read in full; the rest open where the book can be found.

Search Bonaventure at the Internet Archive · every work MannaFest cites

Why this one hangs here

Led the Franciscans through a civil war of their own and mapped the mind's journey up into God.

Hangs on The Fathers: The men who carried the faith out of the apostles' hands, and wrote down what they had received.

Standing beside himThe Long Middle · 51 on this stretch of wall